uima-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Jörn Kottmann <kottm...@gmail.com>
Subject Re: CAS Editor: link feature structure with other FSes
Date Thu, 21 Jun 2012 07:58:50 GMT
Hello,

any suggestions how linking FSes together can be improved in the Cas Editor?

You always need to find the FSes or annotations first to link them
and that always requires a few clicks. It is easy to make this much faster
if there is dedicated view support for a specific labeling task.

Jörn

On 06/20/2012 11:52 PM, Eric Riebling wrote:
> I think a VERY important step is missing from the instructions:
> what to do when you want to link feature structures.
>
> Simply by guessing and trial and error, I was able to come up
> with this solution:
>
>  * By hook or by crook, get the FS into which you want to link
>     another FS into the Edit View panel
>  * Click the lock icon in the Edit View panel, "pinning" it.
>  * By hook or by crook, navigate to the FS you want to link.
>     This is not easy, because the editor is likely in a mode
>     that automatically selects FSes of the type being
>     created, which may not be the type you're linking,
>     so you may have to change modes(!)
>    For me, the best way is to actually use the Outline view.
>  * Find the FS to link in the Outline view, and DRAG it INTO the
>     Edit View panel, into the Value column box of the  feature
>     you're linking it into.
>
> THIS actually seems to work, but it was quite a surprise to discover
> one can drag between panels -nowhere do the instructions mention
> doing anything like this.  *undocumented feature* :)
>
> On 6/20/2012 5:27 PM, Eric Riebling wrote:
>> I know the instructions say that you can create referenced feature 
>> structures
>> including arrays, and that you can link a feature structure with 
>> other feature
>> structures.  But the instructions leave out the details of HOW.  
>> Somehow the
>> phrases "it can be pinned to the edit view" and "This means that it 
>> does not
>> change if the selection changes" are not enough information to 
>> complete the
>> action.
>>
>> What should be pinned, what should be selected?  The annotation being
>> added, or the feature structure being referenced (linked)?
>>
>> I have a suspicion that this is glossing over what CANNOT be done:
>> creating an array of feature structures that are links to other
>> feature structures.  Like an FSArray of uima.tcas.Annotation
>>
>> Here's what I try.  The type being added (let's call it 'Relation') 
>> has a Feature
>> named 'args' which is a FSArray of annotations of type Annotation
>>
>>   * set the CAS Editor Mode to Relation by right-clicking in
>>      the middle of the text and choosing Relation from the
>>      pop-up menu
>>   * select and highlight a range of text
>>   * Type shift-Enter, then type the keyboard shortcut key
>>      for Relation from the pop-up menu
>>   * In the Edit View associated with the newly created Relation,
>>      click on 'args'
>>   * click the plus sign to create an array, and in the pop-up
>>      Array size dialog box, enter for Size: 2
>>   * NOTHING HAPPENS
>>
>


Mime
View raw message