subversion-users mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Johan Corveleyn <>
Subject Re: Checkout through link ignores rev parameter
Date Wed, 25 Jan 2017 15:32:45 GMT
On Wed, Jan 25, 2017 at 2:23 PM, Dalton, Bill (GE Energy Connections)
<> wrote:
> Johan,
> Thanks for your response.
> When I saw this description, I thought, "Oh yes.  That's our problem."  However, I think
the thread I was looking at said it was fixed in 1.6.  Our Subversion server is 1.9.2.  Almost
all of our agents are 1.9.4.  A couple of the agents are 1.7.9.  So, it doesn't seem to be
the same problem.  Or maybe there is a path to get to that failure that wasn't fixed.
> Sorry about the terminology.  I'm not familiar with how these links are implemented.
 I have assumed that they were just Unix links.  I know that what looks like a file is actually
a pointer to another location which contains the actual file.
> Bill

No, the issue I referred you to, SVN-2516 [1] is not fixed, not even
in trunk. It's status in JIRA is "open", and I think that's correct.
The mail thread linked from the issue also ends without a conclusion
(there doesn't seem to be a definitive consensus on how it should
behave, and whether or not the new behaviour would need an option
flag, or if it would become the default). I don't see any mention of a
fix being in 1.6.

Also: externals are quite different from unix symlinks. For starters,
they are a working-copy-only thing ... the server doesn't know /
understand the link. It only sees a property ("svn:externals"), but it
doesn't interpret nor understand this property. It's just the svn
client which does some extra work when it sees such an svn:externals
property, by pulling in the extra items from the pointed-to repository
location into the working copy.



View raw message