cayenne-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Bill Dudney <>
Subject Re: [VOTE] Cayenne 2.0.1-incubating release
Date Wed, 20 Sep 2006 07:43:48 GMT
-1 because of #3 & potentially #4

here are a few of things that I noticed;

1) the .sh files in the bin directory are not executable
2) the jar names in the lib dir do not have 'incubating' in the name  
- this might be an issue with the incubator pmc but we do have  
'incubating' in the root of the directory structure so it's probably ok
3) i could not find the jgoodies, jdom, ongl, scopemvc or hsqldb  
license files or references anywhere. From what I could find here;

it looks to me like we need to explicitly point out that this stuff  
is not from apache

I looked at the struts release (1.3.5) and they simply put a pointer  
to the antlr site from their NOTICE file which I think will be good...

4) the jar files don't have LICENSE & NOTICE files in the META-INF  
folder - it could be unimportant for these jars as they are not  
shipped separately, but the maven repo probably needs them (and yes I  
need to get that done)

I'm open to a +1 cause it runs like a champ. but this legal stuff is  
important and I'd hate for our first incubating release to get  
smacked :-)

Thanks again Andrus for all your hard work on this!



On Sep 18, 2006, at 7:46 PM, Andrus Adamchik wrote:

> Committers and PPMC members, please review and vote on Cayenne  
> 2.0.1-incubating release.
> [ ] +1  Go ahead with the release
> [ ]  0  Don't know or care
> [ ] -1  Reject the release (explain why)
> * release files:
> * release 2.0.1 is a full ASF-compliant equivalent of a non-ASF  
> Cayenne 1.2.1.
> * the release has no known IP issues
> * the release has no (L)GPL or other incompatible license dependencies
> * the release is compliant with Apache guidelines (NOTICE,  
> DISCLAIMER, LICENSE files placement, "incubating" in the naming).
> Would be great to catch any inconsistencies now, before we send it  
> out for the Incubator PMC vote.
> Thanks
> Andrus

View raw message