Hi Alain thanks for your kick reply.

Regarding SimpleStrategy perhaps you are right but it's so easy to add nodes.

I'm not using vnodes and the default 256. The information that I've posted it a regular nodetool status keyspace.

My partition key is a sequencial big int but nodetool cfstatus shows that the number of keys are not balanced (data from 3 nodes):

Number of keys (estimate): 442779640

Number of keys (estimate): 736380940

Number of keys (estimate): 451097313

Should I use nodetool rebuild?


nodetool getendpoints mykeyspace data 9213395123941039285

nodetool getendpoints mykeyspace data 9213395123941039286

All nodes are working hard because my TTL is for 18 days and daily data ingestion is around 120,000,000 records:

nodetool compactionstats -H
pending tasks: 3
- mykeyspace.data: 3

id                                   compaction type     keyspace  table     completed  total      unit  progress
c49599b1-308d-11e7-ba5b-67e232f1bee1 Remove deleted data mykeyspace data 133.89 GiB 158.33 GiB bytes 84.56% 
c49599b0-308d-11e7-ba5b-67e232f1bee1 Remove deleted data mykeyspace data 136.2 GiB  278.96 GiB bytes 48.83%

Active compaction remaining time :   0h00m00s

nodetool compactionstats -H
pending tasks: 2
- mykeyspace.data: 2

id                                   compaction type keyspace  table     completed total      unit  progress
b6e8ce80-30d4-11e7-a2be-9b830f114108 Compaction      mykeyspace data 4.05 GiB  133.02 GiB bytes 3.04%  
Active compaction remaining time :   2h17m34s

The nodetool repair by default in this C* version is incremental and since the repair is run in all nodes in different hours and I don't want snapshots that's why I'm cleaning twice a day (not sure that with -pr a snapshot is created).

The cleanup was already remove was there because last node was created a few days ago.

I'm using garbagecollect to force the cleanup since I'm running out of space.


On 05/04/2017 12:50 PM, Alain RODRIGUEZ wrote:

CREATE KEYSPACE mykeyspace WITH replication = {'class':
'SimpleStrategy', 'replication_factor': '2'}  AND durable_writes = false;

The SimpleStrategy is never recommended for production clusters as it does not recognise racks or datacenter, inducing possible availability issues and unpredictable latency when using those. I would not even use it for testing purposes, I see no point in most cases.

Even if this should be changed, carefully but as soon as possible imho, it is probably not related to your main issue at hand.

If nodes are imbalanced, there are 3 mains questions that come to my mind:

  1. Are the token well distributed among the available nodes?
  2. Is the data correctly balanced on the token ring (i.e. are the 'id' values of 'mykeyspace.data' table well spread between the nodes?
  3. Are the compaction processes running smoothly on every nodes

Point 1 depends on whether you are using vnodes or not and what number of vnodes ('num_token' in cassandra.yaml).
  • If not using vnodes, you have to manually set the positions of the nodes and move them around when adding more nodes so thing remain balanced
  • If using vnodes, make sure to use a high enough number of vnodes so distribution is 'good enough' (More than 32 in most cases, default is 256, which lead to quite balanced rings, but brings other issues)

UN  398.39 GiB  256          28.9%
UN   765.32 GiB  256          29.9%
UN   574.24 GiB  256          28.2%
UN  817.56 GiB  256          28.2%
UN   638.82 GiB  256          28.2%
UN  408.95 GiB  256          28.7%
UN  574.63 GiB  256          27.9%

You can have the token ownership information by running 'nodetool status <mykeyspace>'. Adding the keyspace name in the command give you the real ownership. Also, RF = 2 means the total of the ownership should be 200%, ideally evenly balanced. I am not sure about the command you ran here. Also as a global advice, let us the command you ran and what you expect us to see in the output.

Still the tokens seems to be well distributed, and I guess you are using the default 'num_token': 256. So I believe you are not having this issue. But the delta between the data hold on each node is up to x2 (400 GB on some nodes, 800 GB on some others).

Point 2 highly depends on the workload. Are your partitions evenly distributed among the nodes? It depends on your primary key. Using an UUID as the partition key is often a good idea, but it depends on your needs as well, of course. You could look at the distribution on the distinct nodes through: 'nodetool cfstats'.

Point 3 : even if the tokens are perfectly distributed and the primary key perfectly randomized, some node can have some disk issue or any other reason having the compactions falling behind. This would lead to this node to hold more data and note evicting tombstones properly in some cases, increasing disk space used. Other than that, you can have a big SSTable being compacted on a node, having the size of the node growing quite suddenly (that's why 50 to 20% of the disk should always be free, depending on the compaction strategy in use and the number of concurrent compactions). Here, running 'nodetool compactionstats -H' on all the nodes would probably help you to troubleshoot.

About crontab
08 05   * * *   root    nodetool repair -pr
11 11   * * *   root    fstrim -a
04 12   * * *   root    nodetool clearsnapshot
33 13   * * 2   root    nodetool cleanup
35 15   * * *   root    nodetool garbagecollect
46 19   * * *   root    nodetool clearsnapshot
50 23   * * *   root    nodetool flush

I don't understand what you try to achieve with some of the commands:

nodetool repair -pr

Repairing the cluster regularly is good in most cases, but as default changes with version, I would specify if the repair is supposed to be 'incremental' or 'full', if it is supposed to be 'sequential' or 'parallel' for example. Also, as the dataset growth, some issue will appear with repairs.Just search for 'repairs cassandra' on google or any search engine you are using and you will see that repair is a complex topic. Look for videos and you will find a lot of informations about it from nice talks like these 2 from the last summit:


Also some nice tools exist to help with repairs:

The Reaper (originally made at Spotify now maintained by The Last Pickle): https://github.com/thelastpickle/cassandra-reaper
'cassandra_range_repair.py':  https://github.com/BrianGallew/cassandra_range_repair

11 11   * * *   root    fstrim -a

I am not really sure about this one but it looks good as long as the 'fstrim' do not create performance issue while it is running it seems fine.

04 12   * * *   root    nodetool clearsnapshot

This will automatically erase any snapshot you might want to keep. It might be good to specify what snapshot you want to remove and name it. Some snapshots will be created and not removed when using a sequential repair. So I believe clearing specific snapshots is a good idea to save disk space.

33 13   * * 2   root    nodetool cleanup

This is to be ran on all the nodes after adding a new node. It will just remove data from existing node that 'gave' some token ranges to the new node. To do so it will compact all the SSTables. It doesn't seem to be a good idea to 'cron' that.

35 15   * * *   root    nodetool garbagecollect

This is also an heavy operation that you should not need in a regular basis: http://cassandra.apache.org/doc/latest/tools/nodetool/garbagecollect.html. What problem are you trying to solve here? Your data uses TTLs and TWCS, so expired SSTable should be going away without any issue.

46 19   * * *   root    nodetool clearsnapshot

Again? What for?

50 23   * * *   root    nodetool flush

This will produce tables to be flushed at the same time, no matter their sizes or any other considerations. It is not to be used unless you are doing some testing, debugging or on your way to shut down the node.

Alain Rodriguez - @arodream - alain@thelastpickle.com

The Last Pickle - Apache Cassandra Consulting

2017-05-04 11:38 GMT+01:00 Cogumelos Maravilha <cogumelosmaravilha@sapo.pt>:
Hi all,

I'm using C* 3.10.

CREATE KEYSPACE mykeyspace WITH replication = {'class':
'SimpleStrategy', 'replication_factor': '2'}  AND durable_writes = false;

CREATE TABLE mykeyspace.data (
    id bigint PRIMARY KEY,
    kafka text
) WITH bloom_filter_fp_chance = 0.5
    AND caching = {'keys': 'ALL', 'rows_per_partition': 'NONE'}
    AND comment = ''
    AND compaction = {'class':
'compaction_window_size': '10', 'compaction_window_unit': 'HOURS',
'max_threshold': '32', 'min_threshold': '6'}
    AND compression = {'chunk_length_in_kb': '64', 'class':
    AND crc_check_chance = 0.0
    AND dclocal_read_repair_chance = 0.1
    AND default_time_to_live = 1555200
    AND gc_grace_seconds = 10800
    AND max_index_interval = 2048
    AND memtable_flush_period_in_ms = 0
    AND min_index_interval = 128
    AND read_repair_chance = 0.0
    AND speculative_retry = '99PERCENTILE';

UN  398.39 GiB  256          28.9%
UN   765.32 GiB  256          29.9%
UN   574.24 GiB  256          28.2%
UN  817.56 GiB  256          28.2%
UN   638.82 GiB  256          28.2%
UN  408.95 GiB  256          28.7%
UN  574.63 GiB  256          27.9%

At crontab in all nodes (only changes the time):

08 05   * * *   root    nodetool repair -pr
11 11   * * *   root    fstrim -a
04 12   * * *   root    nodetool clearsnapshot
33 13   * * 2   root    nodetool cleanup
35 15   * * *   root    nodetool garbagecollect
46 19   * * *   root    nodetool clearsnapshot
50 23   * * *   root    nodetool flush

I can I fixed this?

Thanks in advance.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscribe@cassandra.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: user-help@cassandra.apache.org