xml-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Berin Lautenbach <be...@wingsofhermes.org>
Subject Re: [VOTE]: motion to transform Xerces into a top-level project as a member of the "federation" of XML projects
Date Sun, 09 May 2004 09:43:56 GMT
Andy Clark wrote:

> That's where we disagree, I guess. I consider all the parser
> implementations as "Xerces", the TLP. They are built, packaged,
> and shipped separately but I still consider them all the same
> thing at that level. With that view, Xerces-* are all "Xerces".
> Then the sub-projects are collective units below that (e.g.
> HTML). Does that make more sense?

<Much deleted>

OK.  It seems to me that the whole thing is bogging down in 
sub-projects.  And it strikes me that the focus is there because 
everyone is so used to XML where a sub-project is a "big thing"(TM). 
The reason it's such a big thing in XML is because they are all really 
TLPs.  So we put all this control around them when really we should have 
just bounced them up a level (as we are doing now).

IMHO they should not be the focus of attention for Xerces (at least at 
the moment).  When you get to creating sub-projects - *then* look at 
what it means structurally for the project and just go with what works 
best at the time.

So - what I've done is take Neil's words from a month or so back and put 
them on the nagoya wiki.  (I know - smack my hand, we are supposed to be 
using the new one :>.)

Have a look at :


I have taken out *nearly* every reference to any kind of sub-project. 
The thinking is "document what's there today".  Feel free to hack it 
around and modify it until it meets your needs.  Personally I'd cut it 
down even more, but that's your call :>.

That will provide you a draft to allow you to take the resolution to the 
board.  Then once you are a TLP, you can either approve it or modify it 
to your needs.

NOTE : This does *not* have to approved for you to become a TLP.  I am 
simply trying to facilitate an area that seems to be an issue!

I have also put the draft resolution for the board at :


NOTE : This *does* have to be approved (by the board) for you to become 
a TLP, so the next things to do are :

1.  Decide on the initial PMC
2.  Decide on the initial PMC Chair.
3.  Update the resolution as appropriate.

It would be fantastic to have a resolution to the board on the 19th of 
May, but lets see how we go.


To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@xml.apache.org

View raw message