tomcat-users mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Michael DiChiappari <>
Subject RE: System suggestions? Eclipse / Tomcat / JBoss
Date Wed, 21 Jul 2004 13:18:18 GMT
It sounds like you are on the right track.  If you are doing EJBs, then you 
can use JBoss.  Tomcat is just a servlet container.  You may also want to 
consider (when its ready) Apache/Jakarta's J2EE app server.  I think it is 
called Geronimo.

JBoss comes in different flavors.  We have used the one with Tomcat built 
in (to handle servlets).    Eventually we will want to hook this up to Apache.

We have NOT had much success in getting Tomcat to work well with Apache.  I 
would advice against going down that path (especially if you are on 
Linux).  Someday we will probably try to get JBoss to work with Apache and 
I dread the day.  I am hoping the JBoss documentation and support people 
will be helpful.  Unfortunately, the Jakarta Tomcat group is one of the 
worst open source efforts I have seen.  My guess is that the do-ocracy has 
turned into a political mess there, with the most ineffective people 
providing the interface to the (developer) public.

There are lots of commercial alternatives to JBoss.  For developer 
purposes, you can download and utilize just about any J2EE app server for 
free.  The following companies provide developer versions of their app 
servers: BEA (Weblogic), Macromedia (JRun), and Oracle (iAS).  The 
appealing thing about using one of these, is that you can say that you have 
experience on them.  Since they seem to be used by larger, more established 
companies, that may translate into some dollars for you when seeking a new 
job (unless JBoss can break into these markets).

If you are doing EJBs, then you'll need more than Eclipse.  We have used 
the MyEclipse plugin and it is very nice.  It is a commercial product and 
we licensed it for something like $29 per user (about 1/100th the cost of 
JBuilder!).  It includes all the stuff (XDoclet, etc...) for deploying a 
bean (setting up the deplopyment descriptors) and doing servlets/JSPs.  I 
have heard good things about another J2EE pluging called Lomboz.  You may 
want to check that out.

The thing I like about Eclipse is that it hides a lot of Java technologies 
from you.  Thinks like Ant and XDoclet are a feat to learn on their 
own.  However, the development environment hides most of these items from you.

Good luck.

>Hi everybody
>Short version:
>Anybody have suggestions for:
>HTTP Server
>App Server (with EJB support)
>Long version:
>At work we use IBM Visual Age for Java (VAJ), Domino as an HTTP server
>(don't ask) and Websphere as an application server.
>We've been investigating the possibility of switching Eclipse for VAJ
>instead of upgrading to the next version.  We imported our site into
>Eclipse and it compiled well, we deployed it to a test Domino/Websphere
>I've been investigating setting up a variation at home, an IDE, HTTP
>server, App server, that could be used for our
>developing/maintaining/running our site, for the purpose of learning
>more and perhaps coming up with better/cheaper alternatives to VAJ /
>Websphere.  Beginning with Apache, I discovered Tomcat as an app server
>(as Apache is only an HTTP server).  But I understand that Tomcat
>doesn't do EJB's and I've encountered JBoss.
>I'm looking for Open Source software, it's cheap.  But also, software
>that's well established in the community, so that it's not likely to
>fade away.
>Anybody have suggestions for nice, robust, not too difficult, etc.

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message