sling-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Bertrand Delacretaz <>
Subject Re: FYI, playing with Sling, GraalVM and native images
Date Thu, 04 Jul 2019 14:07:01 GMT
H Paul,

Thank you very much for your input!

On Wed, Jul 3, 2019 at 5:30 PM Paul Bjorkstrand
<> wrote:
> ...From what I know of GraalVM/native-image, the biggest hurdles will be with
> classloading (lazy load/hiding bundle-private classes) and reflection...

Yes out of the list at [1] that's what I'm mostly seeing in my experiments.

Figuring out what's causing trouble when adding third-party libraries
can be quite hard as native-image error messages are far from obvious
to me, so I've been going in very small steps and that helps.

> ...The nature of how Felix/OSGi hides nonpublic classes (like you stated #4 on
> SLING-8556) would make it extremely difficult to get this working without
> major changes...

yes, and it looks like just having classes embedded in bundles is a
problem at build time, so I'm not sure if Felix Connect would help
much (but happy to be proven wrong on that one).

> Reflection can be worked around, by providing a list of what can be found
> by reflection...

Yes and the tracing agent mentioned at SLING-8556 helps with that.

> ....It is likely that the entirety of Sling would need to
> be able to run without being inside an OSGi container, before you can get
> native-image to work properly....

Agreed - for now I'm focusing on getting a useful subset of Sling to
run as a native image, using static wiring of the required components.

I have moved my code to - large
parts of it are still Very Ugly (TM), for now I've been able to run
the SlingRequestProcessor in a degraded way, with lots of shortcuts
and mocks - but I do have an HTTP server that starts in a few msec and
runs some Sling core code.

I'll work on fleshing out the SlingRequestProcessor environment next,
to make the example more realistic - but I'm not shooting to run the
whole of Sling in a native image, just some small parts as mentioned.



View raw message