polygene-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Paul Merlin <paulmer...@apache.org>
Subject Re: What is a ValueComposite?
Date Sun, 23 Apr 2017 12:33:59 GMT
Le 2017-04-11 08:23, Niclas Hedhman a écrit :
> Gang,
> I figured out what was going on with the ValueType not containing
> ValueComposite.class for a ValueComposite in a Property of something 
> else.
> It was as I suggested a matter of only checking interfaces during the
> building of the composite models, and hence not looking at any 
> registered
> types.
> But this made me wonder....
> module.values( List.class ).withMixins( MyList.class );
> Property<List<String>> nicknames();
> Is nicknames now a ValueComposite or not?
> It is simply a matter of we have no strong definition when an interface
> "becomes" a ValueComposite.
> And I have no good answer either (mostly because of the sample above), 
> but
> I think we need an answer "now".
> And when does this matter; Well, at the moment I can only think of
> indexing/query and deserialization of entities (again, should a HashMap 
> or
> a MyList be attempted above?)
> Cheers

It's not a definitive answer at all but I would say that a type 
assembled as a value is a ValueComposite:

   module.values( SomeType.class, List.class );

They are required to be assembled as such to be used in state modeling, 

   Property<SomeType> someProperty();
   Property<List<Whatever>> someOtherProperty();

The ValueTypeFactory would then provide a ValueType which is the thing 
used by consumers to take decisions.
As of today, the two methods of ValueTypeFactory will return different 
things for List ... hum hum.
Either a ValueCompositeType or a CollectionValueType.
We clearly need to make this smarter once we know what to do.

View raw message