plc4x-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Julian Feinauer <>
Subject Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?
Date Mon, 04 Mar 2019 12:11:13 GMT

thanks for the clarification.
Then I'm fine with the doc : )


Am 04.03.19, 13:09 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" <>:

    Hi Julian,
    I had an error in my table markup ... in a few minutes the footnotes should appear ...
they're already in the adoc file, but not rendered.
    The document is from a point of view of the to become TLP (Cause otherwise there would
have been more to mention ... "IPMC approval of Releases, Committers, PPMCs", ...
    And as soon as we are a TLP we no longer have a PPMC, but a PMC as the first "P" stands
for "Podling".
    And I think you are misunderstanding the "Board" ... this is not the Incubator PMC (IPMC
is just the short name of that). The Incubator itself is an Apache TLP and has it's PMC. 
    All TLPs report to the Board of the apache foundation. So our Incubator report goes into
one big report of the Incubator project and that is then submitted as a big report to the
    Am 04.03.19, 12:00 schrieb "Julian Feinauer" <>:
        Hi Chris,
        I read the document and I like it.
        A few findings / remarks:
        - is this document from the perspectiv of a incubating project or the (to become)
        - You always mention the PMC (should be (P)PMC for a podling)
        - For a podling the "Yes" is missing for board report approval
        - Do the 1) / 2) / 3) Stand for footnotes? If so, they are missing
        - I think there is a slight rendering issue with the "===" at the bottom left
        But these are just slight remarks (except for the podling vs TLP difference).
        Am 04.03.19, 10:23 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" <>:
            Hi all,
            so I just added [1] (will take a few minutes to be live)
            However I haven't linked it in the menu yet as we haven't discussed it's content.
            In general it describes what we have been doing so far (That's why I took the
liberty to select Consensus Approval for electing new Committers as we have been doing that)
            If you agree, then I would comment in the link and have it appear in the menu.
            Am 04.03.19, 09:59 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" <>:
                Hi all,
                I am currently creating a copy of the content on
                This is generally agreed upon by the IPMC and I a really good summary. I think
we shouldn't do anything different.
                The main idea of copying instead of linking is: If in the future the linked
document would change, we wouldn't notice that.
                Then we could have people coming by referring to the new version and we haven't
realized the changes. This way we could
                Be made aware of changes, discuss them in the project and update our website.
                And 1 and 2 in my initial email weren't meant as alternatives. I think we
should start with all "carried over PPMCs" being "PMCs" and "Comitters"
                As we don't have any Committers that are not PPMCs this is sort of a trivial
assumption ;-)
                The number 2 was just a suggestion, that the list of "Carried over PMCs" should
be all the IPMCs that responded to the "You want to be carried over" Email.
                Am 04.03.19, 09:01 schrieb "Sebastian Rühl" <>:
                    Hi all,
                    I agree to what Julian wrote and would also would vote to graduate.
                    Currently im a bit involved in private projects but during this march
I should find some more time for the project again.
                    On 2019/03/01 20:35:03, Julian Feinauer <>
                    > Hi Chris,
                    > first, thanks for bringing this up and doing all necessary tedious
                    > As this is the first incubating project I'm that heavily involved
I'm lacking the exact feeling but I do not feel "unready".
                    > I think we have achieved a lot since I joined the project and I'm
very happy that we have such a strong core community.
                    > The last release also gave me confidence that we are able to do all
these steps without you (not that we mind if you do it... ).
                    > The next (or the release after) will be performed by Tim and I feel
confident that he will be able to do it easily with our documentation and some help from you
or me.
                    > Regarding the PPMC / PMC question... I would favor the second variant.
                    > We have a pretty big roster (on paper) with many people never seen
on list (or anywhere else).
                    > So I think this could be a good chance to trim it down a bit and
have it in more accordance with the people who really went active for the project.
                    > Tl;dr; Let's do it : )
                    > Julian
                    > Am 01.03.19, 13:49 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" <>:
                    >     Ok ... logo is uploaded ... so that should have been the last
open task (Hopefully)
                    >     Chris
                    >     Am 01.03.19, 13:14 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" <>:
                    >         Hi Justin,
                    >         well most of the red lines were actually false positives:
                    >         - We do have the image and link to the latest events on the
page, however we include it with CSS
                    >         - Also was there a License link (Even if it was previously
called "Apache License", I updated that in the menu and additionally let it output the "Apache"
menu containing that link in the bottom navigation.
                    >         - I added a Trademark disclaimer in the bottom and added
a TM to all Apache products mentioned on the start page.
                    >         - I'll add the logo ... if I find out how to do it ;-)
                    >         And Justin, thanks for reporting this ... that's why we wanted
you on board :thumbsup:
                    >         Chris
                    >         Am 01.03.19, 12:50 schrieb "Justin Mclean" <>:
                    >             Hi,
                    >             > I'll work on the issues reported in [2] ... didn't
know about that page … 
                    >             Nothing major from what I can see but IMO the trademark
notice in the footer need updating.
                    >             Thanks,
                    >             Justin

View raw message