perl-modperl mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Chris Winters <>
Subject Re: is Apache::Request upload->fh lazy or not?
Date Sat, 14 Apr 2001 13:03:41 GMT
* Thomas K. Burkholder ( [010414 04:28]:
> ...
> I'd like to write upload code that shows progress (via a fork and
> refresh header trick - don't worry about that).  What I'm wondering is,
> by the time I get $fh above (or even by the time I'm in the handler for
> all I know) do I already have the entire file uploaded, or is it done
> lazily as reads are performed on $fh?  I'm not very good at reading this
> XS stuff, but I looked at libapreq and from that I suspect it's all done
> up front.  Is there any way to read it incrementally?
> Has anyone solved this problem before?  I want to provide an upload
> function for my web app that shows the user periodic progress or maybe
> even allows them to cancel it part way through.  Is this too much of a
> reach for http/mod_perl?

AFAIK, the server doesn't even start processing the request until the
entire file is uploaded. In the past (when it's absolutely necessary)
I've popped up a tiny Javascript window telling the user to be patient
(or whatever) while the file uploads. The returned page has an
onload() handler which closes the window. It's not a progress bar, but
it's something that hopefully prevents the user from getting
impatient, clicking the browser's 'Stop' button and resubmitting the


Chris Winters (
Building enterprise-capable snack solutions since 1988.

View raw message