pdfbox-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Jukka Zitting (JIRA)" <j...@apache.org>
Subject [jira] Commented: (PDFBOX-391) Remove or replace troublesome test files
Date Thu, 04 Dec 2008 22:34:44 GMT

    [ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/PDFBOX-391?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=12653524#action_12653524
] 

Jukka Zitting commented on PDFBOX-391:
--------------------------------------

I quickly browsed through the test files, and only the following look like something that
I'd feel comfortable redistributing within an Apache project:

    test/input/cweb.pdf
    test/input/data-000001.pdf
    test/input/Liste732004001452_001_0.pdf_0_.pdf
    test/input/openoffice-test-document
    test/input/sample_fonts_solidconvertor.pdf
    test/input/sampleForSpec.pdf
    test/input/simple-openoffice.pdf
    test/input/yaddatest.pdf
    test/pdfreader/debug.xml.pdf
    test/pdfreader/excel.pdf
    test/pdfreader/ollix_test_2005-03-11_bin.pdf
    test/pdfreader/pdfbox_webpage.pdf

Note that there is a clear distinction between using and redistributing something. We could
still come up with a way to use the test suite in our Hudson CI build and individually by
each developer, but we probably can't keep the documents in svn and we definitely can't release
them as a part of PDFBox.

> Remove or replace troublesome test files
> ----------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: PDFBOX-391
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/PDFBOX-391
>             Project: PDFBox
>          Issue Type: Sub-task
>            Reporter: Jukka Zitting
>            Priority: Blocker
>             Fix For: 0.8.0-incubator
>
>
> One issue raised by the license review (PDFBOX-366) is the status of the various test
PDF files included in the test directory. Many of these don't seem to come with a license
that would permit redistribution within an Apache project, so our only option seems to be
to remove or replace the files before we can make the first Apache release.
> The full list of potentially (I haven't looked at all of these in detail so some might
be OK for us to keep) troublesome test files is:
>     $ find test -name '*.pdf'
>     test/encryption/encrypted_doc_no_id.pdf
>     test/input/10101-AR.pdf
>     test/input/601501018.pdf
>     test/input/Exolab.pdf
>     test/input/FreedomExpressions.pdf
>     test/input/Garcia2003b__Correlative_exploration_of_EEG_Signals.pdf
>     test/input/Garcia2004_thesis.pdf
>     test/input/Hd301212.pdf
>     test/input/JavaMail-1.2.pdf
>     test/input/Liste732004001452_001_0.pdf_0_.pdf
>     test/input/Michel2001__Review_p2_structured.pdf
>     test/input/News-Oct-2001-RUS.pdf
>     test/input/OLS2000-rsync.pdf
>     test/input/OSP_framework.pdf
>     test/input/SphericalHomeomorphism.pdf
>     test/input/T05140.pdf
>     test/input/TEST_SetCharSpacing_Error.pdf
>     test/input/amyuni2_05d__pdf1_3_acro4x.pdf
>     test/input/authentication.pdf
>     test/input/c21-5916 .pdf
>     test/input/citi-tr-00-4.ps.gz.pdf
>     test/input/connection_pool.pdf
>     test/input/cweb.pdf
>     test/input/data-000001.pdf
>     test/input/defensive_driving_class_schedule.pdf
>     test/input/ekb_deutsch.pdf
>     test/input/emsv4a4.pdf
>     test/input/fdeb.pdf
>     test/input/frweb-f-332-18.pdf
>     test/input/hexnumberproblem.pdf
>     test/input/irs tax guide for small businesses.pdf
>     test/input/jose-lugo-test.pdf
>     test/input/jun2003.pdf
>     test/input/null_thread_bead.pdf
>     test/input/ocalc.pdf
>     test/input/openoffice-test-document.pdf
>     test/input/org.eclipse.platform.doc.isv.pdf
>     test/input/pdf_with_lots_of_fields.pdf
>     test/input/rc5.pdf
>     test/input/reservedparkingsalaryreductionauthorization.pdf
>     test/input/ruminations.pdf
>     test/input/sampleForSpec.pdf
>     test/input/sample_fonts_solidconvertor.pdf
>     test/input/sha256.pdf
>     test/input/simple-openoffice.pdf
>     test/input/surface_interpolation.pdf
>     test/input/tech_report.pdf
>     test/input/terms_and_conditions_book.pdf
>     test/input/test_rotate_270.pdf
>     test/input/warp.pdf
>     test/input/welcome.pdf
>     test/input/whats_new.pdf
>     test/input/yaddatest.pdf
>     test/pdfparser/genko_oc_shiryo1.pdf
>     test/pdfreader/debug.xml.pdf
>     test/pdfreader/excel.pdf
>     test/pdfreader/ollix_test_2005-03-11_bin.pdf
>     test/pdfreader/pdfbox_webpage.pdf
> My suggestion is that (in line with PDFBOX-368) we create a new src/test/resources directory
where we move all reviewed and accepted test cases. Once all these files have been reviewed,
we just drop the remaining ones for which an acceptable license could not be found. It would
be nice if replacements could be created for such test cases, but in some cases (special PDF
constructs, etc.) that might be a bit troublesome so I guess we'll just need to live with
some reduction in test coverage due to this.
> For more background, see the discussions at http://markmail.org/message/z7meilylwifef7db
and http://markmail.org/message/cuyylr6zqs4fwdiz.

-- 
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.


Mime
View raw message