openoffice-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Regina Henschel <rb.hensc...@t-online.de>
Subject Re: Defaults for 3D drawings
Date Mon, 28 Oct 2013 11:06:30 GMT
Hi Armin,

it seems, I was not precise enough. My question here is not about what 
AOO does when using the UI or what is needed for normal user. My 
question is, what defaults are used, if AOO gets a file, where these 
attributes are not defined. (Of cause, such files have to be written 
manually. I've created a lot of them in the meantime.) The spec allows 
to omit these attributes. But currently the spec gives no default 
values. Therefor my goal is, to suggest default values to be used in the 
spec so, that they align with the default values used in AOO, when 
opening such files.

Can you please look through my points again in the light of missing 
attributes in the file?


Armin Le Grand schrieb:
>      Hi Regina,
>
> On 27.10.2013 22:29, Regina Henschel wrote:
>> Hi all,
>>
>> most (all?) attributes for 3D objects (scene, cube, sphere, extrude,
>> rotate) and for the camera description (vrp, vpn, vup, distance,
>> focal-length, projection) are optional in ODF1.2 but have no defaults.
>> Before I suggest defaults, I want to look, what defaults AOO is using.
>> But I'm a little bit lost in the code.
>
> welcome ;-)
>
>> From the appearance and from some code snippets I guess this:
>> (1) There exists an general interpretation 1cm = 1000 units and 1 unit
>> = 1/100mm for values without explicit unit.
>
> Yes, as everywhere on the DrawingLayer, the unit is 1/100th mm. For 3D
> there is more folatingpoint than for the 2D stuff.

Changing 2D points to floating point is issue 
https://tools.oasis-open.org/issues/browse/OFFICE-386

>
>> (2) The values in svg:viewBox of extrude and rotate are interpreted as
>> 1/100mm, so a value of 8000 will be interpreted as 8cm. The viewBox is
>> interpretated as x-min, y-min, width, height (as in SVG). Negative
>> values in x-min and y-min are allowed, don't know about real numbers.
>> (3) Cube and sphere have a default size of (5000|5000|5000). That
>> results in a sphere with diameter 5cm and a cube with edge length 5cm.
>> (4) Cube, sphere, and inner scene are axis aligned and centered around
>> origin.
>
> The objects have default sizes and tehse are pretty never changed.

But their size can be set in file format directly, without any 
transformation. The problems with that in AOO are in bugs 
https://issues.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=123561 and 
https://issues.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=123542.

  The
> normal user has no clue about 3D scenes and that he actually interacts
> with a 3D scene and not with a 3D object. He does not know about
> 'entering' a 3D scene and that he can work with different objects /And
> he should not have to know, that's why direct interactions with 3D
> scenes are allowed; it would be on us to make things more convenient and
> more accessible).
> The result is that nearly never the default sizes of default 3D objecs
> get changed; exceptions are objects 'converted' to 3D since here their
> initial sizes will vary widely.
>
>> (5) distance = 1cm and focal-length = 1cm
>> (6) vup = (0 | 1 | 0)
>> (7) vpn = (0 | 0 | r/3.5) Where r is the value from svg:width of the
>> outermost scene in unit 1/100mm.
>> (8) vrp = (0 | 0 | r/3.5 + 'distance')
>> (9) projection = perspective
>
> For the camera: There are initial values when an instance of a core
> object is created, but these will not stay for long; the 3D works by
> mapping the contained objects 'optimal' to the 3D scene as 2D object so
> that they 'touch' left/right/upper/lower bound of te 2D scene, adjusting
> the camera as needed. This is more intuitive for the user; he would have
> no clue why only a part of his 3D object is visible and what he might
> have done 'wrong'. Thus, these values are adjusted automatically (the
> whole 3D ViewTransformation is adapted to accomplish this).

So when distance, focal-length, vup, vpn, and vrp are not given in the 
file, then the default values for them depend on the content of the scene?

>
>> (10) Camera settings, svg:width, svg:height, svg:x, and svg:y are
>> ignored for inner scenes.
>
> Yes
>
>> (11) The "photo" of the scene is scaled to svg:width and svg:height of
>> the outermost scene.
>
> The other way around: The content is rendered so that it optimally fits
> the selected 2D range.
>
>>
>> Are these observations correct?
>
> See comments. Hope this helps!

Not in all cases, see my comment at the beginning.

Kind regards
Regina

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org


Mime
View raw message