myfaces-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Ganesh <>
Subject Re: Myfaces 2.0 PPR ResponseWriter impl
Date Sat, 06 Jun 2009 15:36:04 GMT

Let me summarize the arguments against pushing scripts to the eval section:

1. scripts inside <!-- comments would suddenly become executed if  
facelets.SKIP_COMMENTS is false (which is the Facelets default)
2. omitting scripts within the markup may damage the layout
3. script order gets messed up if scripts rendered via startElement 
always come last
4. mojarra doesn't do it

No pro arguments in sight, I guess ...

Best regards,

Werner Punz schrieb:
> Ganesh schrieb:
>>> Well the corner case is this...
>>> If you are outside of an insert or update cycle the problem is 
>>> following: What do you do with a simple issued script tag, you have 
>>> to open an <eval> section in this case
>> What do you want to express with >>outside of an insert or update 
>> cycle<< ?
> Following usecase:
> Someone writes the ppr response directly instead of going through the 
> framework.
> What do you do in case of startElement("script" then
> do you write it out or do you push it into an automated eval section!
> My personal guess is, after a second thought, you dont do anything 
> special, you just should interfere with delayed evals in case an 
> insert or update is issued and not finished, but I am not 100% sure!

View raw message