mxnet-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Pedro Larroy <>
Subject Re: About Becoming a Committer
Date Wed, 13 Jun 2018 05:54:41 GMT
* I personally don't like the idea that comittership status is decided in a
closed mail list. This is not the transparency level that I would expect in
an open source project. I'm happy to receive feedback from others that
might be opposed to my application for committer to know what things could
be improved to get there. I have been doing a plethora of contributions to
the project over a year including ARM support, Android and CI, obviously
some of this work together with my team at Amazon (@lebeg,
@KellenSunderland, @marcoabreu). I don't have visibility on how much longer
one has to wait, or what needs to be improved to get there.

* My team is on-call for CI / CD which is also sponsored by us. To fix
problems promptly we would need write permissions to the repository. This
would normal in any other project, be open source or corporate. I think
it's not effective to be on-call when you can't submit critical fixes and
wait days for a CR. Basically I think everyone responsible or involved in
CI should have access rights. As you know, testing our project is a
challenging task for reasons discussed before.

Please comitters and mentors, provide a solution that allows us to work
more effectively and move the project forward faster, as is vital to make
it easier to contribute so we can attract more users.


On Tue, Jun 12, 2018 at 10:31 AM Yasser Zamani <>

> On 6/9/2018 12:45 AM, Sheng Zha wrote:
> > There have been a couple of offline inquiries from contributors about
> > becoming a committer. From those inquiries, it seems that there’s
> confusion
> > in our community about how to become a committer, so I’d like to take
> this
> > opportunity to clarify.
> >
> > The guideline about becoming a committer can be found at
> >
> I think that page at above link is great but the problem is new visitors
> cannot find it quickly then they ask privately from you. I myself was
> looking for it at, so clicked on
> "Community->Contribute", the I read all page then I saw a link to wiki
> on page i.e. "MXNet Confluence Wiki: Development" where I guessed I
> might find something in wiki so clicked that. Then I saw "Becoming a
> Committer" in left side wiki's menu.
> I think we'll get fewer private inquiries on this if we add a direct
> link about it at
> Regards.

  • Unnamed multipart/alternative (inline, None, 0 bytes)
View raw message