lucene-java-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Tatu Saloranta <t...@hypermall.net>
Subject Re: Keyword search with space and wildcard
Date Sat, 30 Aug 2003 04:09:44 GMT
On Friday 29 August 2003 10:02, Terry Steichen wrote:
> I agree.  One problem, however, that new (and not-so-new) Lucene users face
> is a learning curve when they want to get past the simplest and most
> obvious uses of Lucene.  For example, I don't think any of the docs mention
> the fact that you can't combine a phrase and a wildcard query.  Other
> things that are obviously quite well understood by many members of the
> list, are still less-than-clear to others.  For example, I found (and still
> find) it a bit difficult to find concrete examples/advice of how to get
> good benefit from filters.
>
> My whole point is that this is a *very* powerful and flexible technology.
> But I think it's often very difficult for those most experienced in using
> Lucene to fully appreciate how it looks from the "newbie" point of view.

I agree completely. Perhaps I worded my reply badly; I didn't mean to sound 
hostile towards new users at all -- after all I consider myself to be one (I 
just happened to work on simple improvements to QueryParser and learnt how it 
works). I wish documentation was more complete; perhaps some section could 
list common workarounds or insights. And perhaps incompatibility of phrase 
and wild card queries could be added to document that lists current 
limitations.

I guess the reason I think it's valuable to document the flexibility of query 
construction is that I have been working on something similar (although 
working with database queries) in a system I'm working on, and I have also 
seen systems that have query syntax that's too intertwined with backend 
implementation (for example, while Hibernate is a good ORM, its queries don't 
seem to have backend independent intermediate representation... which makes 
it hard to develop different kinds of backends). So, it's useful to know that 
there are 2 levels of interfaces to Lucene's query functionality.

-+ Tatu +-


Mime
View raw message