jackrabbit-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Christian Sprecher <christian_sprec...@magnet.ch>
Subject node type managment: current state and possible directions?
Date Wed, 09 Jul 2008 04:40:13 GMT
Hi all

I have read several posts regarding current and future directions
regarding node type management. I see that an issue has been created
(https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JCR-322), but the discussion
there seems to be stalled. 

What I am currently wondering is: how *should* node type management work
in your opinion? E.g. looking at the following scenarios:
* a new node type is defined requiring a (not yet) defined node type (as
mandatory property, for example)
1: fails instantly
2: fails the first time a node of such a type is created
3: fails the first time such a node is persisted
(I would expect nr 3)

* a property is declared as being mandatory, but there are existing
nodes of this node type having no such property  
1: fails instantly
2: assumes a default value for this property
3: fails the first time such a node is persisted (being either a new or
an updated one)
(hmm, no clue here :))

* a node type is removed, but is used in another node type definition
1: fails instantly
2: replaces all appearances of this node type with its parent up the
hierarchy (hmm, might be tough with multiple inheritance, but hey :))

* what does happen with older versions of nodes that become incompatible
with the new definition? Are node types versioned too?

I am sure that there are more scenarios, but currently I am more
interested in your general stance on this issue. Especially what is to
be considered part of JCR 2.0 standard and what will be

Thx for your feedback

View raw message