incubator-ooo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Shane Curcuru <>
Subject Re: 18 Jan 2012: SOPA and PIPA Protest Banner
Date Thu, 19 Jan 2012 16:29:14 GMT

On 2012-01-18 11:11 PM, Louis Suárez-Potts wrote:
> Sally,
> On 18 January 2012 22:11, Sally Khudairi<>  wrote:
>> Sorry, Louis -- not ignoring you; have been offsite for most of the day.
> Actually, not a problem. I knew when I posted my first of several
> messages late last night that it was way, way too late. But I had
> waited for ASF to do something obvious on its own behalf, and when it
> didn't--and when no one on the A OO list did, either--I thought at the
> least I'd raise the issue, conscious of its belatedness; indeed, that
> was part of the point, and I should hope that for the next time (and
> there will be no end of next times) we can act before not after it's
> too late.
>> Usually we (ASF Marketing&  Publicity) need more than same-day notice to
>> coordinate such efforts.
>> I know there's been discussion about this on the Membership side as well,
>> but the consensus (thus far) is to not black out *, as was
>> suggested. No further action has been decided upon, IIRC.
> Evidently.
>> Let's also keep in mind that the ASF Infrastructure team need to be kept
>> abreast of any decisions/proposals here as well, as they're the ones capable
>> of pulling the trigger on the site.
> I am conscious of these things. So. Let's imagine that I want to get
> ASF to do something reflecting the will of at least one of its
> podlings. As was pointed out, we here can put up a demonstration. But
> how would I go about persuading the ASF directorate? And is there any
> kind of apparatus (political, technical) that would even allow for the
> entire domain to reflect a banner message? (I'd assume, yes, but one
> never knows.)

By "ASF directorate" do you mean the board?  8-)  In terms of politics, 
I think you'll find the ASF Membership generally stays out of politics, 
at least in terms of official ASF messages (although many Members 
certainly have their own strongly held and blogged views!).  In terms of 
technology, the infra team can provide advice and implement all sorts of 
cool things on the website if necessary.

The list of ASF officers is public:

And this is a somewhat helpful overview of corporate structure:

For this kind of question, it's really first up to a sufficient group of 
ASF Members who also volunteer to help do the work of publishing any 
theoretical top level website message.  Depending on the 
situation, we'd certainly ask press@ for advice on how to make the 
message most effective.  And any official statement would either be 
voted on by the board@, or would be signed by a specific ASF officer, 
depending on what topic it's on.

But historically we've shown that the ASF tends to take official 
positions rarely, and only about fundamental issues that are likely to 
affect all of our projects.  My general impression of the Membership is 
that we don't want to be an advocacy group: we merely want to provide a 
good home for like-minded projects who choose to come here.

Individual projects are obviously allowed to manage their own websites 
as they wish, as long as they respect ASF policy and don't cross the 
line into types of lobbying that we're not allowed to do (for our 
particular kind of non-profit status in the US).

- Shane

> Thanks
> louis
>> Thanks,
>> Sally
>> = = = = =
>> Boston +1 617 921 8656
>> London +44 (0) 20 3239 9686
>> skype sallykhudairi
>> ________________________________
>> From: Louis Suárez-Potts<>
>> To: "ooo-dev@incubator"<>; ASF Marketing&
>> Marketing&  Publicity<>
>> Sent: Wednesday, 18 January 2012, 11:05
>> Subject: 18 Jan 2012: SOPA and PIPA Protest Banner
>> All,
>> Proposal:
>> 1. Let's vote on supporting those who have protested the proposed US
>> bills supposed to combat piracy but actually doing a lot more than
>> that and none of it good. These two proposals: SOPA and PIPA.
>> Wikipedia has a fair account:
>> 2. I would propose we post on the Apache OpenOffice podling site this
>> language, for remainder of the day, to be taken down at the onset of
>> 19 January 2012 GMT.
>> ** The Apache OpenOffice Podling members support those who have
>> darkened their Web sites as a unified gesture to protect the freedoms
>> of the Internet and stop misguided legislation that would threaten
>> them. **
>> I would propose further that we have the text white on a black banner
>> at the top of every podling page.
>> Please vote as soon as you can, as obviously time is of the essence.
>> thanks
>> louis
>> PS I'm cc'ing the ASF marketing and publicity list. Quite possible
>> that Apache will say no, if so, that's fine. Better we act as a body
>> together. But I would also suggest that ASF take the lead here and
>> issue a statement, if they have not done so already.

View raw message