incubator-ooo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From eric b <>
Subject [OT] What is needed for Support Forums to be fully integrated into the Apache project
Date Wed, 07 Sep 2011 21:39:35 GMT
Hi  ******  ,

Le 7 sept. 11 à 22:03, Hagar Delest a écrit :

> Le mar. 06 sept. 2011 17:36:10 CEST, eric b  
> <> a écrit :
>> No, Hagar introduced his pseudo, not himself.
>> I wonder how we can trust people we don't know the identity ?
>> Regards,
>> Eric
> First note that I'm not a PPMC or haven't any other role for the  
> moment in ASF.

Not verifiable, and pointless in the discussion.

> The key persons in the forums and some in the ASF do know my identity.

I read you consider some important people desserve to know your  
identity, but not the "simple joe".

> The ASF gives the possibility to get a public alias even when we  
> sign the iCLA.

That's a very bad thing. If so, it would mean some are the VIP ...  
and the other people are "simple people" in the Apache Foundation ?

> So it means that there is no issue with using an alias. That's part  
> of the Internet.

We are not in the clouds, mention the bad side of the Internet is not  
a good answer either, and FYI, this is no longer true : see the  
current Google war around fake accounts: everybody must being  

Legally, I have even some doubts.

> What would be the point knowing my identity? My real name has quite  
> no visibility on the web because I don't have any occupation having  
> a public aspect.

Again, nobody, excepted not identified people you pretend aware, can  

> I don't believe in Facebook and so on for example so no account.
> I think my credential in oooforum and forum is the  
> only point to be taken into account.

Imagine several people, all working in the same company, all paid to  
provide support, and having the same login password ? I know I'm  
exagerating, but there is no risk after all ...

> Therefore I take your comment as rather insulting.

There is nothing insulting inmy comment, and well, I could say the  
same about you.

To be frank, more you insist, and more your behavior looks  
suspicious. AFAIK, I read all people are equal in the Apache  
Foundation, and there is sane legitimity to ask everybody in the  
group to respect the minimum : being truely identifiable.

The question is imho very important : is it allowed to cheat with the  
identity, inside the Apache Foundation ? I sincerily expect the  
answer is no.

Eric Bachard

Education Project:
Projet OOo4Kids :
L'association EducOOo :
Blog :

  • Unnamed multipart/alternative (inline, None, 0 bytes)
View raw message