incubator-ooo-commits mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
Subject [CONF] Apache OpenOffice Community > (Draft)List Conduct Policy
Date Sat, 23 Jun 2012 12:31:00 GMT
Space: Apache OpenOffice Community (
Page: (Draft)List Conduct Policy (

Change Comment:
Subtly re-worded in some places to remove ambiguity, removed redundant double-spaces and non-breaking

Edited by David McKay:
h2. 1 Respect one another

Discussion is the cornerstone of a project like this and the sharing of viewpoints is crucial,
as is understanding and accepting that many views will differ from your own. By all means
debate rigorously and defend your view point stoutly, but avoid abrasive dialogue and personal
attacks. Give leeway to people who do not have English as a first language. Pause before taking
insult, and pause before responding. There is a difference between robust discussion and steamrollering.
Civility is paramount. Manners cost nothing; we are all capable of self-moderation, and of
being aware of our conduct.

h2. 2 Remember the Apache OpenOffice Mission

“To create, as a community, the leading international office suite that will run on all
major platforms and provide access to all functionality and data through open-component based
APIs and an XML-based file format.”

The AOO project is a place for finding open-source solutions to document creation and consumption.
We believe in making AOO freely available because we are the sort of people who welcome diversity
in others, creativity of all sorts and who enjoy finding the best in all situations.

h2. 3 Be Nice

Not only are there lots of people on this list whose first language is not English there are
some busy readers who, by necessity, have to read things quickly. If other list members are
telling you they do not understand what you wrote, or take your innocent phrasing in a poor
light, take it as a signal that your writing style is too idiomatic or too technical (unlikely
but possible) for others to follow easily. This does not necessarily mean you are mean, wrong
and bad, so just be nice and reword the passage. Assume people are not in "attack mode." We
are all on the same team here.

h2. 4 Don't Respond When You are Angry

Assuming people are not in attack mode means that if you think they are, just now, then probably
you are just misunderstanding their point. Ad hominem attacks, e.g., "You are too dumb to
get this," are a sign that you yourself may not have a good-enough handle on the issue to
explain your point clearly.

h2. 5 Relax

Always remember that unless there is a \*darn\* good reason, nothing gets decided at the ASF
in less than 72 elapsed hours, so your reply can wait until morning. You might even get lucky,
and when you check back somebody else will have posted either what you wanted to say, or something
close enough that you can work with it. Remember that the members of a community mailing list
will get to the list when they can. Most of us do this in our spare time, and in different
time zones. Perhaps the rule of thumb could be to respond no more than once per hour, or once
per day, to any given thread. The highest frequency of responses does not necessarily “Win”
in a community of equals. The most concise and useful post tends to win, because furthering
the dialog and advancing the community's goals is what we all desire.

h2. 6 Get to the point

Write as tersely as possible and edit down as much possible so that other people who are just
as busy as you may quickly get your point without ending up defensive. Of course, balance
is needed. Do not let brevity get in the way of providing enough information. Remember that
people must understand your post in order to understand your point.

h2. 7 Consider trimming the post to which you are responding

People who read emails on small screens are not the only ones who are frustrated by picking
important new information out of tons of stuff they have already read. To trim a post, one
simply remove any parts of the post to which one is replying that are not important to understand
ones reply. If the response to one of these posts is, “What? I do not understand,” then
it may be that too much of the context may have been removed.

h2. 8 What happens on a private list, stays on that list

There are only a few private lists on the project. The PPMC list and the Security Team list
come to mind. Anything you read in a private list is by default a private affair and not to
be spoken of, or copied to, other people who are not members of that private list.

h2. 9 There are going to be exceptions to the rule

All of these guidelines are subject to sanity-testing. A person posting child porn on any or Apache OpenOffice list will be reported to the appropriate authorities and will
not be able to complain that their list privacy has been violated. Ramping up to a release,
there are a lot of postings at high frequency. Sometimes it unavoidably requires a long post
to say what needs to be said.

h2. More Useful Stuff

Apache Tips for Email Contributors --

Apache OpenOffice Mailing Lists --

Change your notification preferences:

View raw message