incubator-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Eric Nyberg <e...@cs.cmu.edu>
Subject Re: [Vote] accept UIMA as a podling - #2
Date Wed, 27 Sep 2006 20:56:28 GMT
[X] +1 Accept UIMA as an Incubator podling
[ ]   0 Don't care
[ ] -1 Reject this proposal for the following reason:

-ehn

Ian Holsman wrote:
> 
> 
> issues addressed in this release:
> 1. updated proposal included
> 2. The first paragraph explains it to a layperson
> 3. OASIS issue addressed
> 
> 
> [ ] +1 Accept UIMA as an Incubator podling
> [ ]   0 Don't care
> [ ] -1 Reject this proposal for the following reason:
> 
> 
> ----8<-------Proposal------8<------
> 
> 
> Hello everyone -
> 
> We are submitting this proposal to the community for a
> new project in the incubator, and look forward to starting to work with
> this community.
> 
> This is a slightly modified and extended version of the proposal that has
> already been posted to general@incubator.apache.org.  The whole mail thread
> can be found 
> [http://www.nabble.com/Proposal-for-a-new-incubation-project%3A-Unstructured-Information-Management-Architecture---UIMA-tf2154324.html

> here].
> 
> If you don't feel like reading the whole thread, the main question that 
> came up was:
> this is all very well, but what does it really '''do'''?  Attempts to 
> answer that question
> where made 
> [http://www.nabble.com/Re%3A-Proposal-for-a-new-incubation-project%3A-Unstructured-Information-Management-Architecture---UIMA-p5986403.html

> here] and 
> [http://www.nabble.com/Re%3A-Proposal-for-a-new-incubation-project%3A-Unstructured-Information-Management-Architecture---UIMA-p5987788.html

> here].  We have since worked some of these into the proposal itself.
> 
> ----
> 
> = Proposal for Incubation Project: Unstructured Information Management 
> Architecture - UIMA =
> 
> == Abstract ==
> 
> UIMA is a component framework for the analysis of unstructured content 
> such as text, audio and video.  It comprises an SDK and tooling for 
> composing and running analytic components written in Java and C++.
> 
> 
> == Proposal:  Unstructured Information Management Architecture framework ==
> 
> Unstructured Information Management applications are software systems 
> that analyze large volumes of unstructured information in order to 
> discover knowledge that is relevant to an end user.  We propose UIMA, a 
> framework and SDK for developing such applications.  An example UIM 
> application might ingest plain text and identify entities, such as 
> persons, places, organizations; or relations, such as works-for or 
> located-at.  UIMA enables such an application to be decomposed into 
> components, for example ''"language identification"'' -> ''"language 
> specific segmentation"'' -> ''"sentence boundary detection"'' -> 
> ''"entity detection (person/place names etc.)"''.  Each component must 
> implement interfaces defined by the framework and must provide 
> self-describing metadata via XML descriptor files.  The framework 
> manages these components and the data flow between them.  Components are 
> written in Java or C++; the data that flows between components is 
> designed for efficient mapping between these languages.  UIMA 
> additionally provides capabilities to wrap components as network 
> services, and can scale to very large volumes by replicating processing 
> pipelines over a cluster of networked nodes.
> 
> This framework has already attracted a following among government, 
> commercial, and academic institutions who previously developed analysis 
> algorithms, but were unable to easily build on each other's works, and 
> who want to be able to evolve their applications by independently 
> upgrading parts, as better technology becomes available.  Applications 
> built with this framework are being used with plain text, audio streams, 
> and image/video streams, identifying entities and relations, converting 
> speech to text, translating into different languages, and determining 
> properties of images.
> 
> The UIMA framework runs components in a flow, passing a common data 
> object containing unstructured information (free text, audio, video, 
> etc.) through the components.  Each component examines the unstructured 
> information and data added by other components, and adds data of its 
> own.  The framework mandates a standardized form of the data being 
> passed, and a standardized form of the interfaces to the components.
> 
> We propose a project to develop, implement, support and enhance this 
> framework (and, over time, other implementations) that comply with the 
> UIMA standard (which has been submitted for standardization work within 
> [http://www.oasis-open.org OASIS].  Members of this community are 
> encouraged to participate in that effort, as well; OASIS has an open 
> approach to granting Technical Committee voting rights to members of 
> OASIS, described here: 
> http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/process.php#2.4.
> 
> The proposal includes both the framework, as well as tools to develop, 
> describe, compose and deploy UIMA-based components and applications. The 
> initial work will be based on the UIMA Version 2 framework code 
> developed by IBM; snapshots of each release of this code are currently 
> made available on [http://sourceforge.net/projects/uima-framework 
> SourceForge]. The Source``Forge versions would be stabilized in 
> maintenance mode, if we are successful in moving to Apache.
> The framework is not specific to any IDE or platform, and does not 
> depend on other middleware.
> Background:
> 
> Databases are core components of nearly all applications; they store 
> information in structured tables.  But more and more of the available 
> digital data is unstructured (e.g. email, web documents, images, audio 
> clips, video streams) with little information (metadata) attached to 
> explain its content or context.  Although many applications have been 
> built to process unstructured data, they have either managed it as a 
> BLOB or they have developed isolated applications for analyzing the 
> content.  In the absence of a standardized means for analytical 
> applications to share insights extracted from the content, analytical 
> applications cannot build upon one another. As a result, the industry 
> has barely begun to tap the value locked in unstructured information.
> 
> Standardization is key to achieving component interoperability, with 
> capabilities to mix components developed in different places and in 
> Java, C++ and other languages.  The Unstructured Information Management 
> Architecture defines standards for component interoperability and 
> application composition that will provide this needed unifying standard, 
> and allow a variety of framework implementations to exist, while 
> preserving the goal of unstructured information analytic component reuse.
> 
> UIMA was built to help developers create solutions that get more value
> from unstructured information more quickly and at lower cost by making
> it easy to reuse and combine analytic modules from different sources 
> into new analytic applications. The architecture and the framework have 
> been validated through work with USA's DARPA which is using it as a 
> standard for key projects with several universities involved in advanced 
> linguistics analysis, such as Carnegie Mellon, Columbia, Stanford and 
> University of Massachusetts.  Other companies, such as the Mayo Clinic 
> and Sloan Kettering, are also building efforts around UIMA.  In 
> addition, over 15 software vendors, including companies such as Inxight, 
> Attensity, Clear``Forest, Temis, SPSS, SAS, Cognos, Endeca, Factiva and 
> others, announced plans to support UIMA.
> 
> The UIMA framework (binary and/or source code) has been downloaded over 
> 8000 times from IBM alphaWorks (http://www.alphaworks.ibm.com/tech/uima) 
> or Source``Forge  (http://uima-framework.sourceforge.net).
> 
> == Rationale ==
> 
> We believe that moving the UIMA framework development to the Apache 
> development community will lead to faster innovation, better integration 
> with other open source software, and broader adoption of UIMA, 
> accelerating the industry's ability to get the most value from text, 
> audio, and video content. The UIMA framework is becoming attractive to 
> developers who want to build components; we believe that having UIMA on 
> Apache will encourage the development of a basic set of open source 
> components that will jumpstart these developers' efforts. One of the 
> first components we see possible synergy with is a search component 
> based on Apache Lucene that would enable semantic search.  We like the 
> concept of the Lucene Sandbox as a way to encourage innovation around 
> UIMA, and would envision something similar for this project.
> 
> 
> == Initial Goals ==
> 
> Some initial work we see in the incubator includes the following:
> 
> * redoing the parts of the tooling that were done as derivative works of 
> Eclipse source code, to
> enable everything to be licensable under the Apache license
> * extending the framework to better support "scale-out"
> * extending the framework to better align with the emerging UIMA 
> Standards work
> * extending the framework to support XMI-based SOAP and/or other service 
> interfaces
> * extending the framework to support OSGi-based approaches to 
> componentization and packaging
> * exploring embeddings of the framework within other interested Apache 
> projects, including synergies with Lucene
> * providing aids to the community to migrate from previous versions of 
> the framework to the Apache version
> * setting up community support: hosting a facility similar to the Lucene 
> Sandbox to encourage innovation and
> experimentation; establishing a wiki and some process to allow better 
> documentation to be developed by the community,
> and linking our existing XHTML documentation via an XSL transform to 
> Apache FOP
> 
> 
> == Current Status ==
> === Meritocracy ===
> 
> Meritocracy seems to us an ideal way to grow the community of developers 
> around UIMA, it being a controlled, rational way to give those who 
> positively contribute, more ability to directly contribute.  This 
> approach also gives contributors one of the best reasons to join the 
> community of volunteers - to be recognized for the merit of their 
> contributions.
> 
> === Community ===
> Currently, the UIMA Framework development is being done by IBM, with 
> input from a group of early adopters in industry and government.  Going 
> forward, we see IBM continuing to support several committers working on 
> it.  We have already begun talking with other people outside of IBM that 
> have expressed interest in contributing towards the development.  This 
> includes members of academic institutions, people working for some of 
> the software vendors that have announced plans to support UIMA, and 
> others from companies that have expressed interest since initial 
> announcements about our open source plans.  Multiple non-IBM people have 
> already expressed desires to become committers.
> 
> === Core Developers ===
> The previous core developers of UIMA are Adam Lally, Thilo Goetz, 
> Marshall Schor, Edward Epstein, Jaroslaw Cwiklik and Thomas Hampp.   
> Many others have also contributed.  The developers come from both the 
> Research and Development parts of IBM.
> 
> === Alignment ===
> UIMA has significant synergy with search applications, and we expect to 
> see integration with Lucene in the future. UIMA makes use of the Apache 
> Portable Runtime (APR) for C++ support.  It is designed to be embeddable 
> into other frameworks, such as web application servers.  Part of UIMA is 
> Eclipse-based tooling.  We use ANT for build scripting.   UIMA has 
> support for various language bindings including C++ and Java; we also 
> have more limited bindings for Perl, Python, and TCL.  UIMA uses Web 
> Services as part of its approach to wiring up components in its domain.  
> It makes use of XML services such as Xerces and Xalan.
> 
> The development of UIMA has been based on merit with open discussion 
> among a distributed team of developers, from both Research and 
> Development organizations.
> 
> === License ===
> 
> The current license for the source code is CPL, with a small number of 
> files licensed under the EPL (Eclipse Public License), because these 
> were created as "derivative works" of existing Eclipse open source 
> code.  When the code base is moved to Apache, it will be relicensed 
> under the Apache license, except for the small number of files licensed 
> under the EPL as derivative works of Eclipse source files.  We plan to 
> work in the incubator to redo these parts, so the entire offering can be 
> licensed under the Apache license.
> 
> The distribution for the C++ enablement layer includes open source 
> components ICU (a Unicode package) which has its own license.  We plan 
> to work with community to properly make use of this non-Apache licensed 
> component. Our current vision for the future of UIMA has it aligning 
> with and incorporating other standards-based open source 
> components/protocols, some of which may have licensing other than the 
> Apache license (for example, the Xml Metadata Interchange (XMI), and the 
> EMF ECore Model from Eclipse); we will work with the community in 
> figuring out how to move forward on this.
> 
> === Other IP ===
> 
> When we requested OASIS to set up a Technical Committee chartered to 
> develop a platform-independent specification for text and multi-modal 
> analysis, we specified that it be set up under the "RF on Limited Terms" 
> mode of the OASIS IP Policy.  "RF" means Royalty Free, and the Limited 
> Terms means companies that are working with us on the Technical 
> Committee are restricted in adding additional terms.
> 
> These are the most liberal terms and make any Essential Claims available 
> to ALL and ROYALTY FREE.
> For the details please refer to:
> 
> * http://www.oasis-open.org/who/ipr/ipr_faq.php
> * http://www.oasis-open.org/who/intellectualproperty.php
> 
> Ultimately of course, there is always a risk that someone in the world 
> holds a patent that can be claimed as Essential. The most any standards 
> organization can do is govern the behavior of those who participate in 
> its work and publicly document the licensing commitment of all 
> participants.
> 
> == Known Risks ==
> 
> === Orphaned Software ===
> 
> UIMA has been in active development for 5 years.  The community of users 
> has steadily grown, and there are now significant commercial and 
> research organizations actively using it.  UIMA is embedded in IBM 
> software products and is delivered through IBM services engagements. IBM 
> has developers assigned to it, and is continuing to support its 
> development.  In addition, several people outside of IBM have already 
> expressed interest in working on UIMA, and have been providing IBM with 
> initial feedback. One of the objectives of starting this Apache project 
> is to provide a meritocratic structure for those people to begin more 
> actively contributing to UIMA.
> 
> === Inexperience with Open Source ===
> 
> The individuals working on this software have background as IBM software 
> developers.  While many of them have experience working with open source 
> software, none of them has had extensive experience contributing to 
> other open source software.  However, IBM as an organization has 
> extensive experience contributing to open source projects and will make 
> available resources to provide guidance to the developers working on 
> this project.
> 
> === Homogenous Developers (work for same company?) ===
> 
> Currently all the developers work for IBM, although they come from 
> different geographically dispersed organizations within IBM.  We will 
> reach out during the incubation time to get others to contribute; we 
> have already received interest from several parties.
> 
> === Reliance on salaried developers ===
> 
> Currently the developers are paid employees of IBM.
> 
> === Relationships with Other Apache Products ===
> 
> We make use of several Apache components (SOAP / Web Services, XML 
> (Xerces, Xalan), languages (Perl), scripting languages (ANT), Apache 
> Portable Runtime.  In addition, UIMA has been embedded in other 
> frameworks, such as web application servers, and integrated with search 
> engines.  We are exploring Lucene extensions that could take advantage 
> of UIMA processed data.  We are currently investigating and prototyping 
> some software packaging concepts based on OSGi; the Apache Incubator 
> project Felix may have relevance as we go forward.  The documentation is 
> being moved to XHTML and plans to use Apache FOP for producing PDF 
> reference materials.
> 
> === An Excessive Fascination with the Apache Brand ===
> UIMA is already being adopted by a wide cross section of users, both 
> commercial and academic, world-wide. Our experience shows that analytic 
> modules can be reused and combined through UIMA making it easier and 
> faster for developers to build new analytic applications for specific 
> industries or domains. Given the diversity of content and analytics that 
> will be required to address the multitude of opportunities - from 
> military intelligence to quality assurance to contact center analytics 
> -- growing this infrastructure so that it better aligns with other major 
> Open Source communities should help accelerate industry's ability to get 
> value from content assets.
> 
> We believe that the Apache community of developers has the experience, 
> background, visibility, and synergistic resources to encourage and 
> foster a vibrant developer community around this project.
> 
> 
> == Documentation ==
> 
> There is a combination Introduction, Conceptual Overview, Tutorial, 
> Tools and Framework User's Guides and References, downloadable from 
> http://dl.alphaworks.ibm.com/technologies/uima/UIMA_SDK_Users_Guide_Reference_2.0.pdf

> 
> 
> 
> == Scope of the project ==
> 
> The project will develop implementations of the UIMA architecture (which 
> is concurrently being submitted to the OASIS standards process), 
> supporting the breadth of platforms that developers working in this 
> field are using, including Java, C++, Perl, Python and TCL; and 
> utilities and tooling to support component and application developers 
> and assemblers / packagers.  It will initially include the Java UIMA 
> framework for UIMA Version 2 (you can see a snap shot of the Version 2 
> release Source``Forge; the delivered code would this code base plus 
> normal incremental bug fixes and improvements), plus additional 
> components (mainly documentation and test cases, which are not currently 
> on Source``Forge).  Over time, the project is expected grow to include 
> supporting various embeddings and integrations with other Apache 
> components such as search engines and web application frameworks.
> 
> Over time, we envision the project becoming an umbrella for related 
> open-source around UIMA, including things like open-source pre-annotated 
> corpora, and hosting a facility similar to the Lucene Sandbox to 
> encourage innovation and experimentation.
> 
> The UIMA framework is primarily a set of libraries (in Java, C++, Perl, 
> etc.), test cases, and UIMA utilities and tools (scripts, plugins, 
> executables, etc.) used to build, test and debug UIMA analytic 
> components.  The tooling includes several Eclipse platform plugins.
> 
> == Initial source ==
> 
> The source currently is maintained in IBM internal software control 
> systems, with a copy of each release placed on SourceForge.  At the time 
> of launch, we plan to contribute the latest version of the code base 
> (with some renaming of package prefixes to reflect apache.org), test 
> cases, build files, and documentation, under the terms specified in the 
> ASF Corporate Contributor License.  We plan to donate the existing C++ 
> enablement layer and the support for Perl, Python, and TCL a few months 
> later than the initial donation; this delay is to give us time to finish 
> preparing that code base for Open Source.
> 
> == ASF resources to be created ==
> 
> Mailing lists:
> * uima-dev
> * uima-commits
> * uima-user (we already have a substantial user community and expect 
> them to turn up at Apache
> soon after we've hopefully been accepted into the incubator)
> 
> For other resources such as Subversion repository, JIRA etc. we hope for 
> guidance from our mentors.
> 
> == Initial Set of Committers ==
> 
> * Michael Baessler (mba@michael-baessler.de)
> * Edward Epstein (eddie@aewatercolors.com)
> * Thilo Goetz  (twgoetz@gmx.de)
> * Adam Lally  (alally@alum.rpi.edu)
> * Marshall Schor (msa@schor.com)
> 
> === Sponsor ===
> 
> We are requesting the Incubator to sponsor this.  Our current vision is 
> that it will become a top level project (other projects that develop 
> UIMA components could become subprojects, for instance).
> 
> === Mentors ===
> 
> * Sam Ruby (ruby@apache.org)
> * Ken Coar (coar@apache.org)
> * Ian Holsman (lists@holsman.net)
> 
> === Section 6: Open Issues for Discussion ===
> 
> 
> -- 
> Ian Holsman
> Ian@Holsman.net
> http://garden-gossip.com/ -- what's in your garden?
> 
> 
> 

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Mime
View raw message