On Jan 19, 2012, at 7:47 AM, Miguel Martín-Forero Ruiz wrote:
> Well, if both logos has been treated as different proposals (althought they
> could be the same) I think that they should be treated separately.
Agreed. If someone submitted two proposals those are separate. If both proposals make it to
a second round. We could certainly give the submitter the chance to withdraw one. I happen
to like a few of these and that will make my vote more difficult. :-)
Regards,
Dave
>
> Just count the number of votes separately:
>
> ID X: total N
> ID X': total M
>
> No, ID X: total N + total M (from ID X').
>
> This situation could be avoided if we'd considered only one of them.
> ---
> [image: Cycle-IT]
> * Miguel Martín*
> Director de Tecnología [image: P] 644 469 698
> [image: E] miguel.martin@cycle-it.com
> [image: W] www.cycle-it.com
> [image: T] @lasneyx <http://twitter.com/lasneyx>
>
>
>
> 2012/1/19 Jonathan Campos <jonbcampos@gmail.com>
>
>> On Thu, Jan 19, 2012 at 9:28 AM, Martin Heidegger <mh@leichtgewicht.at
>>> wrote:
>>
>>> (and: no, its not possible to cheat that way!)
>>
>>
>> I would disagree and say one should be removed if there is a duplicate. The
>> rules of voting state that you should vote for 2 logos. If you vote for the
>> same logo twice with 2pts and 3pts then you've voted 5 pts for one logo
>> which disqualifies other voters. So the person's votes are either not
>> counted or the entry is consolidated. Either way some action needs to be
>> taken for the issue.
>>
>> --
>> Jonathan Campos
>>
|