incubator-esme-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Hirsch, Richard" <richard.hir...@siemens.com>
Subject RE: [UI] Browser Resizing
Date Fri, 06 Feb 2009 11:58:08 GMT
Here is the link to Bill's document: http://esme-dev.googlegroups.com/web/ESME%20Comments%2C%20v1%20r15.pdf?gda=-lJnt1sAAADIsTZigDe4Wl25qsa8lok7Jba8aBAiKvOjDKyDtv_kjMmJ3ovmuWbYr8GEQ-h8Dt-1sxyEJ5jfsVBnpp-dv2tv5dONe4EEFK-Mke7gERS1ewZF2vdCvKU-TDZpFtcP-AU

________________________________

From: Anne Kathrine Petteroe [mailto:yojibee@gmail.com]
Sent: Fri 2/6/2009 12:30
To: esme-dev@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Re: [UI] Browser Resizing



Does anyone have the link to Bill's document still?
I cannot find it anywhere...

/Anne

On 6. feb.. 2009, at 11.25, Darren Hague wrote:

> Hi Anne,
>
> I agree with your analysis - I think that the size of a window is 
> the user's decision, not the application's. While it may be OK 
> sometimes for a desktop application to size itself, I think you are 
> right in pointing out that this is a bad idea for a browser-based 
> app.  Of course, the app may work better or worse at any given size, 
> but ideally it should deal gracefully with resizing by the user.
>
> Cheers,
> Darren
>
>> Hi,
>>
>> before we move on with the development of a new web UI, I would like
>> to comment on the use of browser resizing.
>>
>> Based on the drawings in Bill's document, it looks like the UI will 
>> be
>> living in it's own browser window to work best.
>> When I look at the design it looks like it is sometimes not a full
>> browser window but more like  a floating box in a broswer window to 
>> me.
>> See "The Shrunken  Window" chapter for instance.
>>
>> I see a possible problem with a UI that runs in a separate browser
>> window. Most modern browsers (FF, IE7+, etc) use tabs.
>> Most users have learned to use multiple tabs rather than multiple
>> browser instances.
>> Therefore, resizing the entire browser window based on ESME-related
>> changes would cause problems with the other applications that are in
>> that browser instance.
>>
>> The problem for me with this is that I would never use a UI which
>> needs a seperate window. (unless I am forced to use IE6)
>> My browser window is always set to 1024px with at any given time at
>> least 5 open tabs. Google Reader, gmail, twitter and SDN are the four
>> services I *always* have open as tabs.
>> I would like to see a UI which doesn't affect the size of my browser
>> window, which means in any give state is no wider than 1024 px.
>>
>> What do others say about this issue?
>>
>> /Anne
>
>
>
> --
> darren.hague@fortybeans.com




Mime
View raw message