incubator-cvs mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Apache Wiki <wikidi...@apache.org>
Subject [Incubator Wiki] Update of "November2015" by MarvinHumphrey
Date Wed, 04 Nov 2015 04:36:43 GMT
Dear Wiki user,

You have subscribed to a wiki page or wiki category on "Incubator Wiki" for change notification.

The "November2015" page has been changed by MarvinHumphrey:
https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/November2015?action=diff&rev1=49&rev2=50

Comment:
Normalize Mentor/shepherd comments.

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
- The community continues to show great, open development activity on the mailing list.  The
first release was handled well with careful attention to detail when IPMC members requested
a second RC with some changes.  I would like to request that the infra team prioritize completion
of the JIRA migration tracked in INFRA-10144.  --cnauroth
+   Chris Nauroth (cnauroth):
  
- There have been some questions regarding which committers in the project are also on the
PPMC.  Originally only 6 developers were proposed for initial committers, but as part of the
entry to incubation this was expanded to the current 30+.  The understanding of some in the
project was that the PPMC still only consisted of those original 6, while the other ~24 devs
were just committers.  The mentors have explained that it does not work this way.  The community
is talking through how to approach this disconnect.  The mail thread is at https://mail-search.apache.org/members/private-arch/apex-private/201510.mbox/%3CCAKJfLDMPP0-m4vpjM_hZjUDZ_Vvy_z53T1Dyb28eH+qFUvoKiQ@mail.gmail.com%3E
--gates
+     The community continues to show great, open development activity on the
+     mailing list.  The first release was handled well with careful attention
+     to detail when IPMC members requested a second RC with some changes.  I
+     would like to request that the infra team prioritize completion of the
+     JIRA migration tracked in INFRA-10144.
  
+   Alan Gates (gates):
+ 
+     There have been some questions regarding which committers in the project
+     are also on the PPMC.  Originally only 6 developers were proposed for
+     initial committers, but as part of the entry to incubation this was
+     expanded to the current 30+.  The understanding of some in the project
+     was that the PPMC still only consisted of those original 6, while the
+     other ~24 devs were just committers.  The mentors have explained that it
+     does not work this way.  The community is talking through how to
+     approach this disconnect.  The mail thread is at
+     <http://s.apache.org/qsV>.
  
  --------------------
  AsterixDB
@@ -286, +301 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Chris Mattmann (mattmann):
+   
- Great work!
+     Great work!
  
+   Ted Dunning (tdunning):
+ 
- The handling of the Gerrit question was particularly good. -- tdunning
+     The handling of the Gerrit question was particularly good.
  
  --------------------
  Blur
@@ -399, +418 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
- [johndament]:
+   John D. Ament (johndament):
+ 
-   There are a couple of concerns raised in this report, specifically that
+     There are a couple of concerns raised in this report, specifically that
-   ASF infrastructure is not the canonical source of truth for the podling
+     ASF infrastructure is not the canonical source of truth for the podling
-   and limited external participation.
+     and limited external participation.
- 
  
  --------------------
  Concerted
@@ -467, +486 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Julian Hyde (jhyde):
+ 
-  Good level of activity; beginning to engage with community beyond
+     Good level of activity; beginning to engage with community beyond
+     initial committers.
-  initial committers. -- Julian Hyde
- 
  
  --------------------
  Cotton
@@ -807, +827 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Ted Dunning (tdunning):
+ 
- There was a bit of confusion about the graduation vote (which passed, but 
+     There was a bit of confusion about the graduation vote (which passed,
- not unanimously). IPMC and Kylin project members are working to fix the 
+     but not unanimously). IPMC and Kylin project members are working to fix
- issues to the satisfaction of the IPMC member who voted -1. -- tdunning
+     the issues to the satisfaction of the IPMC member who voted -1.
  
  --------------------
  MADlib
@@ -948, +970 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Chris Mattmann (mattmann):
+ 
- REEF voting on graduation.
+     REEF voting on graduation.
- 
  
  --------------------
  Ripple
@@ -1056, +1079 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
- s.b. Getting things started took a bit, presumably due to the review needed to get the code
out, but the fledging community has been responsive to feedback. The next month should give
a better idea of how strong a hand the mentors will need to use.
+   Sean Busbey (busbey):
  
+     Getting things started took a bit, presumably due to the review needed
+     to get the code out, but the fledging community has been responsive to
+     feedback. The next month should give a better idea of how strong a hand
+     the mentors will need to use.
  
  --------------------
  Sirona
@@ -1391, +1418 @@

    [ ](unomi) Chris Mattmann
  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
- [Chris Mattman]:
+ 
+   Chris Mattmann (mattmann):
+ 
-   Missing report.
+     Missing report.
  
- [johndament]:
+   John D. Ament (johndament):
+ 
-   Missing podling status file, no website yet.  Really new podling.
+     Missing podling status file, no website yet.  Really new podling.
  }}}
  

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: cvs-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: cvs-help@incubator.apache.org


Mime
View raw message