incubator-cvs mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Apache Wiki <wikidi...@apache.org>
Subject [Incubator Wiki] Update of "January2014" by MarvinHumphrey
Date Mon, 06 Jan 2014 07:36:01 GMT
Dear Wiki user,

You have subscribed to a wiki page or wiki category on "Incubator Wiki" for change notification.

The "January2014" page has been changed by MarvinHumphrey:
https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/January2014?action=diff&rev1=53&rev2=54

Comment:
Normalize shepherd/mentor commentary.

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Justin Mclean (jmclean):
+ 
- Project is off to a good start with lots of activity on the mailing
+     Project is off to a good start with lots of activity on the mailing list
- list and in JIRA. Mentors are not very active but there are no issues
+     and in JIRA. Mentors are not very active but there are no issues that
- that need attention.
+     need attention.
  
  --------------------
  BatchEE
@@ -228, +230 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
- BatchEE is a new podling, with a small team working on it currently.  It's a fork of the
RI for Java Batch from Java EE 7.  I think short term they should focus on getting a release
out there to draw in community interest; which should help build the podling more and drive
feature interest.
+   John Ament (johndament):
+ 
+     BatchEE is a new podling, with a small team working on it currently.
+     It's a fork of the RI for Java Batch from Java EE 7.  I think short term
+     they should focus on getting a release out there to draw in community
+     interest; which should help build the podling more and drive feature
+     interest.
  
  --------------------
  Celix
@@ -288, +296 @@

    [X](celix) Roman Shaposhnik
  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
- This podling is growing. They plan a release soon and let's see how that goes. When it comes
time for graduation I have some concerns that this podling's community may be too small.
+ 
- Dave Fisher (wave)
+   Dave Fisher (wave):
  
+     This podling is growing. They plan a release soon and let's see how that
+     goes. When it comes time for graduation I have some concerns that this
+     podling's community may be too small.
  
  --------------------
  log4cxx2
@@ -340, +351 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Christian Grobmeier (grobmeier):
+    
- Grobmeier: the podling is just getting started
+     the podling is just getting started
- 
  
  --------------------
  MetaModel
@@ -404, +416 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Roman Shaposhnik (rvs):
  
- ---- /!\ '''Edit conflict - other version:''' ----
- (rvs) In general project seem to be on the right track with a healthy amount
+     In general project seem to be on the right track with a healthy amount
- of community interaction happening over the mailing list and a strong
+     of community interaction happening over the mailing list and a strong
- desire to do a release. Two issues have caught my attention though:
+     desire to do a release. Two issues have caught my attention though:
+ 
-    1. I am not quite sure what motivated a strong drive towards having
+     1. I am not quite sure what motivated a strong drive towards having
-       by-laws this early in the game. In my experience the focus on by-laws
+        by-laws this early in the game. In my experience the focus on by-laws
-       can, at times, put a damping factor on community growth. IOW, what
+        can, at times, put a damping factor on community growth. IOW, what
-       I've seen in the past is that communities try to come up with by-laws
+        I've seen in the past is that communities try to come up with by-laws
-       when the usual process of consensus building starts to fail. Nothing
+        when the usual process of consensus building starts to fail. Nothing
-       actionable here for the project -- just keep this in mind.
+        actionable here for the project -- just keep this in mind.
-    2. The JIRA feels a bit empty for the project that has been developing
+     2. The JIRA feels a bit empty for the project that has been developing
-       for more than 6 month (grand total of 33 issues). At the same time
+        for more than 6 month (grand total of 33 issues). At the same time
-       the number of commits in the Git repo is on par with the development
+        the number of commits in the Git repo is on par with the development
-       pace. What it tells me is that there's no strong correlation between
+        pace. What it tells me is that there's no strong correlation between
-       JIRAs and commits. This raises a red flag of whether all of the changes
+        JIRAs and commits. This raises a red flag of whether all of the changes
-       that are committed get a proper community vetting before they go in.
+        that are committed get a proper community vetting before they go in.
-       I couldn't find any traces of the review requests either:
+        I couldn't find any traces of the review requests either:
           https://reviews.apache.org/groups/metamodel/
-       This in my opinion is a pretty big concern for the project.
+        This in my opinion is a pretty big concern for the project.
- 
- ---- /!\ '''Edit conflict - your version:''' ----
- 
- ---- /!\ '''End of edit conflict''' ----
- 
  
  --------------------
  ODF Toolkit
@@ -478, +486 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
- ODF Toolkit has been incubating for a long time.  Activity on their list is in frequent,
but active enough that it still is running.  Considering what the project is, I think the
best resolution for this podling is to graduate as a sub project under something like OpenOffice
or POI.
+   John Ament (johndament):
+ 
+     ODF Toolkit has been incubating for a long time.  Activity on their list
+     is in frequent, but active enough that it still is running.  Considering
+     what the project is, I think the best resolution for this podling is to
+     graduate as a sub project under something like OpenOffice or POI.
  
  --------------------
  Olingo
@@ -590, +603 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
+   Roman Shaposhnik (rvs):
+ 
- (rvs) The project appears to be doing well
+     The project appears to be doing well
  
  --------------------
  Samza
@@ -755, +770 @@

  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
  
- Seems like a nice active project.  IMO, there's no need to wait import to JIRA to graduate.
Seems like they can graduate now.  - Alan Cabrera
+   Alan Cabrera (acabrera):
+ 
+     Seems like a nice active project.  IMO, there's no need to wait import
+     to JIRA to graduate. Seems like they can graduate now.
  
  --------------------
  Stratos
@@ -814, +832 @@

    [ ](stratos) Noah Slater
  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
+ 
-  Raphael Bircher (rbircher)
+   Raphael Bircher (rbircher):
+ 
-   The project looks realy active. continue like this guys!
+     The project looks realy active.  Continue like this guys!
- 
- 
  
  --------------------
  Twill
@@ -928, +946 @@

    [ ](vxquery) Radu Preotiuc-Pietro
  
  Shepherd/Mentor notes:
+ 
-  Raphael Bircher (rbircher)
+   Raphael Bircher (rbircher):
+ 
-   The mailing list traffic is not verry hight. Whoever, the basic discoussions are on the
lists.
+     The mailing list traffic is not very high. However, the basic
+     discussions are on the lists.
  }}}
  

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: cvs-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: cvs-help@incubator.apache.org


Mime
View raw message