incubator-clerezza-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Hasan <>
Subject Re: Resolving / Closing issues
Date Thu, 18 Feb 2010 06:32:02 GMT


On 02/17/2010 10:05 PM, Reto Bachmann-Gmuer wrote:
> I suggest the following usage of the Jira issue resolved and closed.
> - An issue is marked as resolved if the developer would like to have
> somebody look at, depending on the level of confidence the developer
> has in the proposed solution, the urgency of the issue and the number
> of projected and files affected[1] the proposed resolution is in trunk
> or in an issue branch. The issue will stay with this status till
> somebody reviewed the proposed solution and either closes or reopens
> the issue. To prevent that many do the same review at this stage, the
> reviewer adds the comment "Review" when they start. Any committer may
> request a proposed solution to be removed from trunk, this has the
> same effect as a veto on a closed issue.
> - An issue is marked closed either by the developer or the reviewer
> when the proposed solution has been committed to trunk and no second
> opinion is explicitly wished. With the closure of an issue a lazy
> consensus vote for 72h is opened on the proposed solution. If a veto
> is cast the issue is reopened and the person committing the solution
> must undo the change immediately [2] (but everybody else is free to do
> so), if more recent patches require the vetoed issue, the conflicting
> patches are removed and the respective issues reopened as well.
> Reto
> See also:
> 1. If an issue affects many projects and file it gets harder to merge
> it back, so the cost of the branch is higher. If an issue branch is
> wished for an issue affecting many projects (I'd say, more than 4) it
> might be better clone the whole parent into the issue branch rather
> than the individual projects.
> 2.It need not disappear from the history, but the truk version must be
> changed back as if the change had never happened, an article on how to
> "rollback":

   Hasan Hasan
   trialox AG
   Binzm├╝hlestrasse 14, CH-8050 Z├╝rich
   Tel: +41 44 635 7577
   Fax: +41 44 635 7574

View raw message