Hmm. I thought that Cassandra would encode the composite column without the colon and that it was only there for illustration purposes, so the suggestion to use ~ is confusing.  Are there some docs you can point me to?  Also, after some reading, it seems to me that it is not even possible to have a composite column together with a regular column in a column family in this manner.

On Wed, Mar 28, 2012 at 12:34 AM, R. Verlangen <> wrote:
Yes, that is one of the possible solutions to your problem.

When you want to retrieve only the skills of a particular row just get the columns with as start value "skill:".

A suggestion to your example might be to use a ~ in stead of : as separator. A tilde is used less often in standard sentences, so you could replace any of them in skills with some other character (e.g. a dash or whitespace).

2012/3/27 Ben McCann <>
I was given one other suggestion (which may have been suggested earlier in this thread, but is clearer to me with an example).  The suggestion was to use composite columns and have the first part of the key name be "skill" and the second part be the specific skill and then store a null value.  I hope I understood this suggestion correctly.

user: {
  'name': 'ben',
  'title': 'software engineer',
  'company': 'google',
  'location': 'orange county',
  'skill:java': '',
  'skill:html': '',
  'skill:javascript': ''

On Tue, Mar 27, 2012 at 12:04 AM, samal <> wrote:
YEAH! agree, it only matter for time bucket data.

On Tue, Mar 27, 2012 at 12:31 PM, R. Verlangen <> wrote:
That's true, but it does not sound like a real problem to me.. Maybe someone else can shed some light upon this.

2012/3/27 samal <>

On Tue, Mar 27, 2012 at 1:47 AM, R. Verlangen <> wrote:
" but any schema change will break it "

How do you mean? You don't have to specify the columns in Cassandra so it should work perfect. Except for the "skill~" is preserverd for your list.

 In case skill~ is decided to change to skill:: , it need to be handle at app level. Or otherwise had t update in all row, read it first, modify it, insert new version and delete old version.

With kind regards,

Robin Verlangen

With kind regards,

Robin Verlangen