incubator-cassandra-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Ned Wolpert <ned.wolp...@imemories.com>
Subject Re: Which client API to choose?
Date Wed, 24 Mar 2010 15:12:17 GMT
I recommend Hector myself. I've been using it inside a groovy plugin and it
works well. Also, it abstracts out the connection to Cassandra, gives you
the ability to pool resources, etc.

Think of thrift as JDBC, and Hector as PoolMan. (if anyone remembers that
wonderful project) You're still basically using thrift, just giving you some
nice wrappers and features not there normally.

Not sure the 'fat client' is the way to go... from what I read, doesn't
sound like it.

2010/3/24 Roland Hänel <roland@haenel.me>

> Hi,
>
> First of all, thanks all of you guys who are contributing to this amazing
> project. I've been looking at Cassandra for a couple of days now, and I'm
> still impressed by the whole thing.
>
> However, it wasn't all that straight-forward getting my first "hello world"
> programs to run with Cassandra. As a newbie I was (probably as many of those
> who do their first steps with Cassandra) in doubt with API to choose, and
> the Wiki and examples provided little help here. I have to add that I'm
> playing with 0.6.0beta3, maybe that's the reason the Java Thrift API doesn't
> work like in the Wiki examples (but I was able to adapt to make it working).
>
> Still, I'm somewhat confused which API to choose if I was heading for a
> bigger project
>
> 1. plain Thrift (for Java)?
> Seems the major advantage is that Thrift is available in many languages,
> but if I'm only interested in Java that doesn't give me much. The Java code
> on the native Thrift interface looks quite awful. It also seems to me as if
> it would result in many lines of code even for quite trivial jobs.
>
> 2. a higher level Java Client?
> I didn't look at Hector right now, however it confused me somewhat that if
> something like Hector was the "best choice", why isn't this then bundled
> with Cassandra?
>
> 3. the "native Java fat Client"
> I started some experiments with it, however couldn't get it completely
> working, documentation in the Wiki is not really usuable at all. Question
> would be if this is something that you (the developers) consider as the "big
> thing for the future" or is this some niche for lets say high performance
> bulk jobs but not for the "everyday Java client program"?
>
> Maybe someone could give me a hint in which direction things should move.
>
> Best regards,
> Roland
>
>


-- 
Virtually, Ned Wolpert

"Settle thy studies, Faustus, and begin..."   --Marlowe

Mime
View raw message