If, at any time while processing the request, the URL is rewritten such that a bogus identifier is replaced with an identifier for a valid resource, then that request should result in a 301 response. The only exceptions are internal subrequests for SSI and places where there is a known browser bug that can't handle the 301. This isn't in the RFCs -- it is part of the model for how resources work on the Web (a.k.a. my dissertation). ....Roy