hc-commits mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From mbe...@apache.org
Subject svn commit: r381534 - in /jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt: commons-httpclient-lessons.apt goals-scope.apt
Date Tue, 28 Feb 2006 01:52:01 GMT
Author: mbecke
Date: Mon Feb 27 17:51:58 2006
New Revision: 381534

URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewcvs?rev=381534&view=rev
Added HttpClient lessons learned

    jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/commons-httpclient-lessons.apt   (with props)

Added: jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/commons-httpclient-lessons.apt
URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewcvs/jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/commons-httpclient-lessons.apt?rev=381534&view=auto
--- jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/commons-httpclient-lessons.apt (added)
+++ jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/commons-httpclient-lessons.apt Mon Feb 27 17:51:58
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
+   ----------
+    Lessons Learned - Jakarta Commons HttpClient
+    ----------
+    ----------
+    ----------
+Lessons Learned
+    The HttpComponents project was undertaken following our experience in developing and

+    supporting Jakarta Commons HttpClient. The shortcomings and inefficiencies 
+    listed below emerged during our work with HttpClient and prompted our action. HttpComponents

+    is an attempt to address these issues.
+* Monolithic design of Commons HttpClient
+    * The use patterns of Commons HttpClient have evolved much since its first release. We

+    have found HttpClient used in applications it was never specifically designed 
+    for: in spiders, in server side services such as HTTP proxies or light-weight HTTP 
+    connectors. Essentially we saw HttpClient users trying to use it as a toolkit of generic

+    HTTP components. In some areas the original monolithic design of Commons HttpClient 
+    proved quite lacking.
+    * HttpClient has a rich set of features. Some of them, however, are used infrequently
+    a limited number of specific cases, and represent unnecessary code bloat for a sizable

+    percentage of HttpClient users. Moreover, some of those infrequently used features in

+    Commons HttpClient were introduced at the expense of the API clarity. There are some

+    core HTTP components that are required by all HTTP services whether they be on the client
or on the 
+    server side. More application specific aspects of HTTP, however, cannot be adequately

+    represented by one monolithic library. 
+* Inherent API deficiencies of Commons HttpClient
+    * HttpMethod interface, one of the most fundamental interfaces in Commons HttpClient,

+    is inherently flawed. It tightly couples the HTTP request and HTTP response and implies
+    to one relationship between the two, which is not always the case.
+    * Abuse of inheritance. HttpMethodBase class contains the greatest chunk of processing

+    logic in HttpClient. It inseparably couples the logic of generating HTTP requests and

+    processing HTTP responses. This makes it virtually impossible to create a custom 
+    implementation of an HttpMethod interface, essentially rendering it useless. In practice
+    HTTP methods must be derived from HttpMethodBase class.
+    * The fact that all HTTP methods in practical terms must be derived from one common 
+    base (HttpMethodBase) has a number of side effects. For instance, if one needs to
+    introduce a common behavior across all standard HTTP methods, one would have to 
+    subclass all the existing subclasses of the HttpMethodBase: GetMethod, PostMethod, etc.
+* External dependencies
+    * One of the most frequently cited complaints is its dependency on Commons Logging and

+    Commons Codec. We would like to give the users an option to use core HTTP components

+    without any external libraries and a minimal footprint.
\ No newline at end of file

Propchange: jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/commons-httpclient-lessons.apt
    svn:executable = *

Modified: jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/goals-scope.apt
URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewcvs/jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/goals-scope.apt?rev=381534&r1=381533&r2=381534&view=diff
--- jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/goals-scope.apt (original)
+++ jakarta/httpcomponents/trunk/src/site/apt/goals-scope.apt Mon Feb 27 17:51:58 2006
@@ -10,6 +10,8 @@
     developing and supporting Jakarta Commons HttpClient. The following set of goals are
     derived from our experience with HttpClient and serve as the philosophical foundation

     to HttpComponents.
+    {{{commons-httpclient-lessons.html}Lessons Learned - Jakarta Commons HttpClient}}
 * Componentized design

View raw message