hadoop-hdfs-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From java8964 <java8...@hotmail.com>
Subject RE: Reading multiple input files.
Date Fri, 10 Jan 2014 16:04:38 GMT
The hadoop is very flexible for underline storage system. It is in your control,  how to utilize
the cluster's resource, include CPU, memory, IO and network bandwidth.
Check out hadoop NLineInportFormat, it maybe the right choice for your case.
You can put all the metadata of your files (data) into one text file, and send this text file
to your MR job.
Each mapper will get one line text from the above file, and start to process data representing
by this one line text.
Is it a good solution for you? You have to judge it by yourself. Keep in mind followings:
1) Normally, the above case is good for a MR job to load data from a third party system, for
CPU intensive jobs.2) You do utilize the cluster, as if you have 100 mapper tasks, and 100
files to be processed, you get pretty good concurrency.
1) Are your files (or data) equally split around the third party system? In the above example,
for 100 files (or chunks of data), if one file is 10G, and the rest are only 100M, then one
mapper will take MUCH longer than the rest. You will have lone tail problem, and hurt overall
performance.2) NO data locality advantage compared to HDFS. All the mappers need to load the
data from a third party system remotely.3) If each file (or chunk data) are very large, what
about fail over? For example, if you have 100 mapper task slots, but only 20 files, with 10G
data each, then you under-utilize your cluster resource, as only 20 mappers will handle them,
the rest 80 mapper tasks will be just idle. More important, if one mapper failed, all the
already processed data has to be discard. Another mapper has to restart from beginning for
this chunk of data. Your overall performance is hurt.
As you can see, you get a lot of benefits from the HDFS.  You lost all of them. Sometimes
you have no other choices, but have to load the data on the fly from some 3rd party system.
But you need to think above, and try to seek all the benefits which HDFS can provide to you,
from the 3rd party system, if you can.

Date: Fri, 10 Jan 2014 01:21:19 -0800
Subject: Reading multiple input files.
From: kchew534@gmail.com
To: user@hadoop.apache.org

How does a MR job read multiple input files from different locations?

What if the input files are not in hdfs and located on different servers? Do I have to copy
them to hdfs first and instruct my MR job to read from them? Can I instruct my MR job to read
directly from those servers?


View raw message