gump-general mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Stefano Mazzocchi <>
Subject Gump as TLP
Date Sat, 31 Jan 2004 03:03:58 GMT
Dear board,

this is an informal email to test the waters and see what would be the 
reason for the proposal of Gump as top level project.

As you might know, Gump is the continuous integration tool that is used 
in the java-related projects around apache. It was built by Sam in a 
way to test early contract changes in between project dependencies. It 
is *not*, as many believe, a nightly build system.

Sam described Gump as a social experiment. I still like the definition, 
but things have changed since Sam decided to step down and follow other 

Most notably, the creation of Gumpy, a forked version of Gump that does 
the same thing and uses the same data, but it was entirely rewritten in 

You can appreciate the difference between Gump and Gumpy following 
these links:

  1) Gump ->

  2) Gumpy ->

Gump was written in a mixture of XML,XSLT,shell scripts and java, Gumpy 
is written entirely in Python and uses Forrest as the HTML rendering 

There is currently a community of 4 developers actively working on 
Gumpy and since all ASF committers have access to the gump database for 
project dependencies, it's hard to keep track of how many different 
people actually contribute to Gump.

In my mind, I think Gump needs to step out of jakarta for a number of 

1) it is *NOT* related to jakarta only (it never was, but being java 
focused, jakarta was the place to forge it)

2) it is not even using java as a programming language anymore!

3) top level would increase its visibility and would bring more 
attention to the fact that early-one contract failure detection would 
massive improve our ability to move forward yet keep massive amount of 
dependencies (as it's the normal case in the java world, as you can see 
from the gump numers of some of those project dependencies)

4) the gump development community voted all +1 on the proposal when I 
ran it thru them.

                                          - o -

So far for the introduction.

Here is my proposal:

1) move Gump out of jakarta and create it as a full ASF project, with 
PMC and all that

2) setup on minotaur and let that be the project web 

3) install a running gump on moof or in some of the new IBM boxes (when 
they come) and proxypass it to (or some other URL 
like that)

That's all for now, please let me know your comments.

Ah, please, don't impose some "" or something like that 
on us: we are not doing this to trade one container for another.

View raw message