geronimo-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From mett <>
Subject Re: Solved! Re: Geronimo WTP client for eclipse doesn't work as expected
Date Thu, 28 Feb 2008 08:10:12 GMT

Ok Tim, here I go...

A little more documentation on the website wouldn't hurt.

* When a new user finds the page
there should be a little more info available. Like the one I found out. (See
the post from me starting with Solved!)
* A newbie also might be interested in the page and especially
in the section Users FAQ. Finally there he/she only finds questions...
* Maybe a cooperation with the maven guys could end up with a special goal.
eclipse:geronimo perhaps that would solve the issue beforehand if using

I believe fixing the first two might do the trick for newbies though.

PS. I finally must let you know, although this isn't really allowed
according to the rules of the mailing list, that I appreciate your attention
in this matter. I still have post out there, other forums, that hasn't been
answered yet, mind you years has passed. DS.

Tim McConnell-2 wrote:
> HI Mett, well I glad you found the problem, although I'm not happy that it
> took 
> so long. Do you have a suggestion for how we might make this more obvious
> to 
> users like you who may not be as familiar with either Geronimo or the
> Geronimo 
> Eclipse Plugin. All suggestions are welcome. Thanks
> mett wrote:
>> Hi!
>> Finally I found the source to the problem. When a project is created
>> within
>> eclipse, an eclipse that has the Geronimo WTP client installed the
>> Targeted
>> Runtime is set to Apache Geronimo as a default.
>> For my project that was created outside eclipse this isn't the case.
>> After comparing every little detail between these projects I found that
>> setting Apache Geronimo v2.0 as a targeted Runtime changes was noticed by
>> Geronimo. Looking back this seems quite obvious, it wasn't for me believe
>> you me.
>> over and out! // mett
>> mett wrote:
>>> Thanks for all your effort so far Tim,
>>> However I haven't found the solution yet but I have an hunch on where
>>> the
>>> error might be.
>>> Since the project is renewed when it is removed from the server via "Add
>>> and Remove Projects..." menu option but not when the WTP is signaling
>>> changed files I believe the Geronimo is looking for changed files in the
>>> wrong place. As I mentioned before the Geronimo Server changes state in
>>> the Servers view in Eclipse but the console stays the same.
>>> I believe that the cause for this might be that the project structure
>>> isn't "default" eclipse but a deeper hierarchy painted by maven. 
>>> When I create a project within eclipse the change in an jsp or html page
>>> is instantly reflected in the web browser.
>>> Is there something in some configuration file that I need to look at.
>>> Please kick me in the right direction.
>>> Tim McConnell-2 wrote:
>>>> Hi Mett, let me take a stab at your questions.....
>>>> 1. You are looking in the right place, but as you know WTP is very
>>>> large
>>>> with 
>>>> many feature and plugins such that the precise version of WTP is
>>>> somewhat 
>>>> obfuscated (at least as far as I know). What you may want to consider
>>>> is
>>>> to 
>>>> possibly start with a new Eclipse installation and download what is
>>>> required to 
>>>> run the version of the GEP that you wish to use. If you want to use GEP
>>>> 2.0 you 
>>>> can get the list of prereqs from here:
>>>> --->
>>>> I would recommend just using the ant script since it'll save you a LOT
>>>> of
>>>> time 
>>>> by downloading everything for you (except the JDK), and unzipping it
>>>> into
>>>> an 
>>>> eclipse directory that you can use to create your new eclipse
>>>> installation. 
>>>> Also, these are the latest maintenance versions of WTP and the other
>>>> prereqs. If 
>>>> you don't want maintenance versions but would rather use official
>>>> released 
>>>> versions you can use this ant script instead....
>>>> ---> 
>>>> 2. Frankly, I don't know much about the BEA jrockit JDK. It may be
>>>> fine,
>>>> but 
>>>> Geronimo and the GEP are developed and tested only on Sun JDKs, and I
>>>> would 
>>>> recommend the same for you just to be safe.
>>>> 3. If you following the recommendations in #1, #2 above you will also
>>>> want to 
>>>> start with a new Eclipse workspace as well and then define the Geronimo
>>>> server. 
>>>> If not, then you definitely need to delete and redefine you Geronimo
>>>> Server 
>>>> Definition.
>>>> Hope this helps. Thanks.
>>>> mett wrote:
>>>>> Hi Tim,
>>>>> First of all it's really nice to get such a swift response to a
>>>>> question
>>>>> of
>>>>> mine, Thanks!
>>>>> However I have a couple of follow up questions:
>>>>> 1. Where is the place to verify the version numbers in Eclipse? When
>>>>> look
>>>>> at Help/About Eclipse Platform/Feature Details I find them all but
>>>>> WTP.
>>>>> This
>>>>> is strange to me since I am sure I have installed this. Going further
>>>>> down
>>>>> into the Plug-In Details I find a lot of plug-ins starting with the
>>>>> letters
>>>>> WTP but then with the wrong version number. I don't even think they
>>>>> are
>>>>> related to the true WTP.
>>>>> 2. How important is the Sun JDK 5.0? I am running on jrockit 1.6.0_01.
>>>>> 3. Now, after finishing with updates of all updatable plug-ins there
>>>>> are
>>>>> I
>>>>> still can't find the WTP plugin in the Feature Details list. I now
>>>>> know
>>>>> that
>>>>> this is installed since I just did it (again). Where can I verify its
>>>>> existance?
>>>>> Within the Plug-in details dialog I find these WTP(?) plugins: WTP EJB
>>>>> UI
>>>>> Plug-in, WTP J2EE UI Plug-in, WTP JCA UI Plug-in, WTP Servlet UI
>>>>> Plug-in,
>>>>> WTP UI Plug-in, WTP Webservice UI Plug-in. These doesn't seam to be
>>>>> directly
>>>>> related but they start with WTP.
>>>>> The IDE is restarted a numerous of times, Do I need to reinstall the
>>>>> Geronimo server after I updated all of these features?
>>>>> Best Regards
>>>>> Mett
>>>>> Tim McConnell-2 wrote:
>>>>>> Hi Mett, I see the problem on our trunk version of the Geronimo
>>>>>> Eclipse
>>>>>> Plugin 
>>>>>> (GEP) and Geronimo server. It works fine for me though on my 2.0.2
>>>>>> version
>>>>>> of 
>>>>>> the Geronimo and Plugin. I'm guessing at this point that it might
>>>>>> a
>>>>>> WTP 
>>>>>> problem, but will have to do a bit more analysis/debugging to ensure
>>>>>> that
>>>>>> is the 
>>>>>> case. Thanks much for bringing this to our attention....
>>>>>> mett wrote:
>>>>>>> Hi,
>>>>>>> I am quite new at Geronimo at the moment. I have up to now been
>>>>>>> using
>>>>>>> JBoss
>>>>>>> as an integrated application server in my Eclipse IDE. Since
I am
>>>>>>> all
>>>>>>> but
>>>>>>> impressed of the way that server handles memory and redeploy
I am
>>>>>>> interested
>>>>>>> in trying out the Geronimo application server.
>>>>>>> The status at the moment is that I have the Geronimo server 2.0.2
>>>>>>> installed
>>>>>>> and working. I have a deployment plan that works and I think
>>>>>>> the
>>>>>>> performance is better. 
>>>>>>> My problem is the automatic redeploy that I can't get to work
>>>>>>> all.
>>>>>>> When I
>>>>>>> alter an jsp page or a java class the WTP reacts and the server
>>>>>>> starts
>>>>>>> a
>>>>>>> redeploy but there isn't any change in the appearance or the
>>>>>>> in
>>>>>>> the
>>>>>>> server structure.
>>>>>>> For a change to have affect I need to remove the project with
>>>>>>> Add
>>>>>>> and
>>>>>>> Remove Projects... menu option. Restart the server and the add
>>>>>>> project
>>>>>>> again. This is a bit more tedious than using JBoss; to describe
>>>>>>> mildly.
>>>>>>> The action is exactly similar regardless of how the installation
>>>>>>> been
>>>>>>> done. First I installed Geronimo by hand and the WTP from within
>>>>>>> eclipse.
>>>>>>> I
>>>>>>> all worked as above. After that I tried to do also the Geronimo
>>>>>>> installation
>>>>>>> from within eclipse. Then I got 2.0.1 with the JRE_HOME issue
>>>>>>> upgraded
>>>>>>> to 2.0.2 with the above result.
>>>>>>> I am using Maven to set up and manage my projects so the compiled
>>>>>>> files
>>>>>>> end
>>>>>>> up in target/classes if this is an issue.
>>>>>>> Please guide me, I want to use Geronimo and I refuse to believe
>>>>>>> it
>>>>>>> is
>>>>>>> intended to work this way.
>>>>>>> Best Regards
>>>>>>> Mett
>>>>>> -- 
>>>>>> Thanks,
>>>>>> Tim McConnell
>>>> -- 
>>>> Thanks,
>>>> Tim McConnell
> -- 
> Thanks,
> Tim McConnell

View this message in context:
Sent from the Apache Geronimo - Users mailing list archive at

View raw message