geronimo-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Dave Colasurdo <davec...@earthlink.net>
Subject Re: User Feedback Request -- this means you!
Date Wed, 05 Apr 2006 20:07:09 GMT
I tried to order them by priority (based on number of times mentioned) 
within each category/sub-category..  The ones that were mentioned the 
most are first on the list and so forth..  Items that were mentioned 
only once are listed in random order..

Anyway, I've updated the list below with the number of requests for each 
item.   I've denoted with *(number)*.  Absence of a number indicates one 
request for an item.

Of course the community needs to digest the input and decide on  priorities.

BTW, I have added Global JNDI ENC to the list..

If folks agree with the format, I will post to the wiki..

-Dave-


Matt Hogstrom wrote:
> This is great Dave...I think we need to prioritze them as well.  Can you 
> translate the priorty from the other e-mails to this?
> 
> Matt
> 
> Dave Colasurdo wrote:
>> Excellent feedback from all..
>>
>> Here is an attempt to consolidate the feedback into one list. (Hope 
>> I'm not stepping on anyone's toes.)  I've grouped by a few high level 
>> categories..
>> Of course, one could argue that some of the items could fall into 
>> multiple categories...  Any glaring omissions?
>>

Specifications/Functionality
****************************
-JDK 5 for Geronimo *(11)*
-JEE 5 *(3)*
   Enterprise JavaBeans 3.0 *(5)*
   Java Servlet 2.5
   Java ServerPages 2.1
   Java ServerPages Standard Tag Library
   Java Persistence Architecture (is this part of Java EE?)
   Java Transaction API (JTA)
   J2EE Management
   J2EE Connector Architecture
-JAX-WS support *(4)*
-GBean improvements (doc, lifecycle, dependencies, dep. injection, ..) *(2)*
-Dynamic Queries *(2)*
-javax.persistence
-annotated session beans.
-Support for JSR-168 (Portlet API)
-ServiceMix
-Maven2 support
-service/daemon wrapper
-Remove the requirement of the openejb-jar.xml??
-Better db tools in the admin console
-Configuration management, possibility to make a production version 
without some current modules (e.g. OpenEJB or ActiveMQ),
   there are end users who don't have the resources (memory, disk) to 
run Geronimo fully equipped and they don't need every
   feature of the J2EE stack
- Continued support of Jetty
-First class HttpSession clustering.
-More integration with Apache mod_JK/mod_ajp . It would be nice if a 
request would continue through a pool until it landed
on a server with that webapp.
-Mass deployment tools that allow the server 'cloning' and rollout 
mentioned during Geronimos initial days.
-Global JNDI ENC

Tools
*****
-NetBeans support *(3)*
-JDK 5 for launching and running the Geronimo Eclipse plugin *(2)*
-Eclipse plugin improvement (it is really good but think it could be
better)
-Eclipse mini-roadmap (from Sachin)
   - run resources directly from the workspace, so the ear isn't built 
and re-packaged on every publish
   - More control over the runtime/server wizards, publish process, and 
server management
   - Continue to build up the UI so we have a complete set of "form 
editors" for the G deployment plans
   - ability to see changes reflected live in something like the Common 
Navigator as you modify your plans
   - full synchronization between the source view and views using the model
   - copy/paste, undo/redo support
   -There's also plans in WTP to improve the Server Tools Framework to 
make it easier to have more control over what defines your runtime.


Usability
*********
-Deployment *(5)*
   Less deployment requirements (simpler plans, more defaults, etc.)
   Simplifying deployment (some means to generate geronimo deployment plans?
   Easier  way to  deploy  EAR Files
   More application validation at deployment
   Better redeployment to prevent requests from failing if they hit that 
server during the  redeploy.
-More powerful text configuration
-Migration path from Tomcat to Geronimo
-Shortcuts for building web services


Process
*******
-More frequent releases incorporating more user feedback (small releases 
  more often vs. big releases only 4 times a year) *(7)*
-Geronimo Certified Partner Program (including Jetspeed-2 as a member). 
*(2)*


Documentation *(10)*
*************
-Tutorials *(4)*
   How to use Geronimo with: Apache Axis, WSS4J, ActiveMQ
-Cookbooks
-Better documentation on deployment descriptors
-More detailed documentation about the architecture and Gbeans *(2)*
-A browsable table describing where to find all plans, etc. for each 
deployed component or service.
-More documentaion on deploying EAR's, WAR's, EJB's, RAR's, classloading 
and dependencies with that apps)

Examples *(4)*
********
-Examples for everything
-More documentation/examples for me should be more explicative models of 
the basic openejb-jar.xml and ejb-jar.xml,
    explaining which tag points where or what
   Session beans, entity beans(BMP and CMP)
   Message-Driven-Bean.


>>
>> -Dave-
>>
>>
>>
>>
> 
> 

Mime
View raw message