geronimo-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Chris Dodunski <>
Subject RE: JavaWorld Article and Certification Claims
Date Tue, 14 Dec 2004 22:47:28 GMT
Hi Lajos,

Perhaps you could elaborate, and write that Geronimo aims to be the first
certified J2EE server, and the first genuine open source BSD licensed J2EE
server (I haven't read your article).  JBoss is licensed under the more
restrictive LGPL license.

It's unfortunate that JBoss has felt the need to attack Geronimo, but
understandable.  On the one hand JBoss has benefited hugely from Apache's
presence, but on the other hand Geronimo looks set to take the puff out of
JBoss's sails.


-----Original Message-----
From: Lajos [] 
Sent: Wednesday, 15 December 2004 8:40 a.m.
Subject: JavaWorld Article and Certification Claims

Hi y'all -

I'm engaged in a bit of argument on my article for JavaWorld on 
Geronimo. I said that Geronimo will be (I should have said wants to be) 
the first open source J2EE 1.4 certified application server. JBoss has 
complained to JavaWorld, saying that they are already the first. In 
fact, I don't consider JBoss open source like Geronimo. JBoss being open 
source is like Solaris 10 being open source - it is two different 
models. I think the distinction is not only important, it is vital. I 
don't like the idea of major corporations being able to coopt the term 
open source as a marketing ploy. It is dangerous for the open source 
community and takes us back to the reason why open source got started in 
the first place.

While I won't completely retract my statement in my article (I'll change 
"will be" to "hopes to be"), I'd be interested in seeing if anyone else 
agrees with my position or even sees the problem I'm pointing out.




                    Lajos Moczar
     Open Source Support, Consulting and Training
                  Tomcat Unleashed

             Cocoon Developer's Handbook

                    _      _____
                   / \         /
                  /___\      /
                 /     \   /____ -- powered by AzSSL

View raw message