Mailing-List: contact dev-help@geronimo.apache.org; run by ezmlm
Precedence: bulk
Reply-To: dev@geronimo.apache.org
Received-SPF: neutral (athena.apache.org: local policy)
Message-ID: <49380DDE.8090502@apache.org>
Date: Thu, 04 Dec 2008 12:05:34 -0500
From: Donald Woods <dwoods@apache.org>
User-Agent: Thunderbird 2.0.0.18 (Macintosh/20081105)
MIME-Version: 1.0
To: dev@geronimo.apache.org
Subject: Re: Download link on the main page
References: <5294C098-630D-4652-AE3C-47A0D0D0952B@planet57.com>
 <4938066B.5080907@earthlink.net>
 <0D61C446-B2A7-4E73-9BB7-2C300E9D6FB3@planet57.com>
In-Reply-To: <0D61C446-B2A7-4E73-9BB7-2C300E9D6FB3@planet57.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

Agree that we need a more prominent "Download" graphic/button on the 
home page.  Maybe using the Box logo and adding "Download Now" text 
under the existing "Apache Geronimo" text would suffice.

Also, I've been thinking that we need similar "Tooling" and "Docs" 
graphics.  Sort of like the Apache DS project has -
	http://directory.apache.org/


-Donald


Jason Dillon wrote:
> I think that the current download link is fine for more savvy folks.  So 
> defs leave that there.
> 
> However I think that we should add a new big-ass download button under 
> the big-ass G logo saying "Download" which takes you to a page that 
> *picks* the latest distribution for you to download (with not much else 
> on the page), sans some links to how to use it, and a link to the 
> current download page for more download options.
> 
> The current link in the side-nav is not predominate, so it may cause 
> some users some searching to find it, smart ones finding it sooner than 
> others... but even I was like where is the download link earlier today 
> when I needed the latest G dist to test with.  I found it shortly, but 
> thats me... from looking at other sites, javaee and really other tools, 
> a lot of them have a big-ass simple to find "Download" or "Download Me 
> Now" button, so the brain doesn't have to work... just click.
> 
> I wrote this email because we are lacking that "feature"... it should be 
> simple to add it and its to the groups benefit...
> 
> I'm trying to think like someone who hasn't been in open-source for 
> years and years, dug the net for rpms, recompiled kernels with patches 
> I've found on nntp... more like if I told my mom about G, could she 
> figure it out with out an hour long skype conference?  Okay, probably 
> not... but right now I'd probably still need to have a 30m chat to 
> explain the download link and the difference between 
> javaee/little-g/frame+jetty/tomcat... er shit, okay bad example cause 
> that would still take me a long as time to explain to my mom... but you 
> get my drift?
> 
> --jason
> 
> 
> On Dec 4, 2008, at 11:33 PM, Joe Bohn wrote:
> 
>> Are you proposing this "in addition to" or "instead of" the current 
>> Downloads link under Overview on the left?
>>
>> If we do add or replace the link I think it should continue to point 
>> to the overall download page: http://geronimo.apache.org/downloads.html
>>
>> Joe
>>
>> Jason Dillon wrote:
>>> I think that the main G page ( http://geronimo.apache.org/ ) is 
>>> missing a rather large nice looking "Download" button.  I think it 
>>> would fit really nicely under the big G logo.
>>> IMO it would be good if this link took you directly to the latest 
>>> releases download page, that being here right now:
>>>    http://geronimo.apache.org/apache-geronimo-v213-release.html
>>> And somewhat related the "Java EE 5 Certified" section for downloads 
>>> seems a bit crunched up the by text on the right.  I've got a 30" 
>>> display and a*reasonable* size browser screen and it still is hard to 
>>> read.
>>> I'd like to see that "Apache Geronimo v2.1.3 have passed..." text 
>>> below the table, above "Download Sample ..." which should really help:
>>> * * *
>>> Anyways, its not like its hard to find Downloads, then under Latest 
>>> Release -> Apache Geronimo v2.1.3 Release...
>>> Its just that it seems like the *norm* for sites to include that 
>>> big-ass overpowering "Download" button on the first page that users 
>>> see to take them directly to the page where they get the good stuff.
>>> Also, somewhat related... might confuse some users as to which 
>>> distribution they should download... TAR or ZIP?  Jetty or Tomcat... 
>>> JavaEE or Little... wtf... which one... okay screw it I'll go look at...
>>> I know a lot of us know how to find what we want... and IMO the site 
>>> is tailored to that (short of the icky formatting noted above, I had 
>>> to read the thing a few times to find the right dist).  But is the 
>>> site really for  you or me?  ie.... non-average joes (and no plumber 
>>> comments here please)?  I don't think it is... the main goal besides 
>>> providing a consistent navigable informative experience is to make it 
>>> fricken simple for anyone to quickly grab a copy of G and play with it.
>>> IMO the site right now doesn't do that... but I'd like to see it.  
>>> Say I'm a virgin user, heard about this cool free G-thing... so I go 
>>> hit the website.  I really don't care about *anything* short of how 
>>> do I download the *right* version, install it and start to play with 
>>> it, so I can then go to my boss and say hey look at this cool stuff 
>>> we can use.
>>> * * *
>>> Basically, if we can make a Download button on the main page, which 
>>> takes the user to an uber simple page with the link to the dist they 
>>> want, it could help a lot.  That page should have a link to the 
>>> suggested download, and then a page to the current release page in 
>>> case they want more options.
>>> Can't decide if its jetty or tomcat?  Well make it random them, cause 
>>> they both work the same... but IMO the added option just confuses 
>>> people.  After they understand more by playing with it they will get 
>>> that the web stuff is pluggable or they won't care and keep using 
>>> whatever we suggested (randomly) for them.
>>> * * *
>>> Confluence driven site does present some issues here, but we can 
>>> create a custom usermacro to handle so Its definitely possible.
>>> Okay... me shuts up now... hope y'all didn't tune out... I think this 
>>> is important, even though my ranting style might be hard for some to 
>>> grok.
>>> :-\
>>> --jason
>>
> 
>