geronimo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Kevan Miller <>
Subject [DISCUSS] specs versioning
Date Mon, 11 Dec 2006 18:13:21 GMT
The versioning policy for our geronimo specs has been floating around  
for a while now. I'd like to see this issue resolved.

There have been two approaches discussed

1) Single version -- all specs are released under the same version  
2) Separate version -- each spec is versioned separately from the  
other specs.

Dain created a review of the two proposals in the wiki -- http:// I think  
you can quibble over a few of the details, but it does a good job at  
summarizing the issue.

IMO, there are going to be drawbacks no matter which approach we  
take. However, I'm going to be happy with either approach as long as  
we reach a *decision*. I'd prefer that we reach consensus on this  
discussion thread. However, if necessary, we can vote on the issue.

Personally, I think we should use a single version for releasing our  
specs. I think this makes it easier for us as developers in managing  
spec releases. I think users will find it easier to collect a  
consistent set of specifications. I think these benefits outweigh  
concerns over the lack of flexibility and the wasteful aspects of re- 
releasing unchanged specifications.

I suppose there's a hybrid option where we release separate versions,  
now, and move to a single version policy (2.0?) for our next release.


View raw message