geronimo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Prasad Kashyap" <>
Subject Re: Java EE 5.0
Date Wed, 08 Nov 2006 18:04:43 GMT
I like the idea of branching out 1.2 and making trunk 2.0. It will
bring isolated java EE5 code out of the different people's sandbox. We
can get a headstart on integrating them all together and also getting
our builds and tests to work on jdk 1.5.

(IMO, a sparse tree for Java EE5 won't generate that not that much
interest either, esp. when we ask folks to go and builds two trees.)

However, we should also make a serious effort to roll up the bug fixes
from the 1.2 branch to the Java EE5 branch (or trunk or whatever you
want to call it). Just recently we had to tag a trunk as dead and
re-do a lot of work. Let history not repeat in this case.

Top 3 reasons to have a Java EE5 branch:
1. The race is on.
2. demand from the industry/users
3. interest in the development community to work on it.

These reasons are strong enough to outweigh the cons (all and any) in
not doing so.



On 11/8/06, Kevan Miller <> wrote:
> On Nov 8, 2006, at 11:01 AM, Matt Hogstrom wrote:
> >
> > 4) Change trunk to 2.0-SNAPSHOT and turn it into M1 as it stands.
> > No TCK required...incremental move towards Java EE 5.0 (due to
> > JPA), greater relevance to our users, and its a win for everyone.
> >
> > Personally, I don't think branching is the optimal solution and in
> > reality I think its suboptimal.  However, based on the feedback
> > from the JUGs, the performance report on the TSS and talking to
> > people they are more interested in Java 1.5 and Java EE 5.0 than
> > another 1.4 certified release.  This also means that we don't have
> > to invest effort in a 1.2 release which is always time consuming.
> Didn't mean to ignore your previous note... My mail must have been
> out-of-sync...
> That certainly works for me... I'm interested to hear from others --
> especially those who have been working on 1.2... They've made a
> tremendous amount of progress (which greatly benefits JEE5, btw...).
> --kevan

View raw message