geronimo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Geir Magnusson Jr <>
Subject Re: [VOTE] 1.0.1 Release and the configId issue
Date Thu, 02 Feb 2006 06:56:47 GMT
What's the timing?  I ask with motivated by the thought that the sooner 
it happens, the fewer people will be affected...


Matt Hogstrom wrote:
> There was some discussion on Irc earlier this week about the issue 
> related to plans having to be changed due to module versions changing.  
> This is clearly going to be a significant issues for customers as they 
> will have to re-work all their plans on incremental server changes.  
> Although these will most likely be tolerated in the short-term this is a 
> serious shortcoming in the current design that needs to be addressed.
> During the discussion it was asserted tha given the magnitude of the 
> change to the format of the plans and changes to G it was not 
> appropriate for make this change in a maintenance release.  The 
> collective wisdom was to declare in the release notes this issue and 
> give the user guidance with the assurance this is being addressed in 1.1 
> (or there abouts).
> Since there has been a lot of discussion about this already and it being 
> such a significant issue I thought I'd request a vote to see where we 
> stand.
> [ ] +1 Document issue in release notes and defer fix to 1.1
> [ ] 0  Not that important one way or another
> [ ] -1 This is an issue that must be resolved in the 1.0.x branch
> [ ] Other...provide your reasons.

View raw message