geronimo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Hernan Cunico <>
Subject Re: JMS documentation update
Date Tue, 24 Jan 2006 20:55:10 GMT
Thanks for the input Aaron. I will work on this comments.


Aaron Mulder wrote:
> Hernan,
> I now see the download link to the RAR and EAR files, which I believe
> improves the usefulness of the document.
> However, I have some issues with this RAR:
> 1) There is no license in the ra.xml
> 2) It is not clear where the source code is (if indeed it is available)
> 3) It uses the org.apache.geronimo package, but it is not actually
> part of Geronimo, nor is the code hosted at Apache at all as far as I
> know
> 4) The documentation is not clear that this is a 3rd-party RAR, it
> actually makes it seem kind of like part of Geronimo
> 5) The config-property/description elements in ra.xml do not contain
> any helpful descriptions.  The JMS configuration features in the
> console rely on these, so if you can put a detailed description in
> there for each config-property, it will be possible to configure JMS
> resource groups for this RAR in the console.
> I would be much more comfortable if you changed the package name used
> by the code, and called the whole thing something less like
> "gerjms.rar" and more like "external-jms-for-geronimo.rar".
> Finally, the article has a very small section on ActiveMQ, but does
> not actually give any hints or examples on how to configure JMS for
> ActiveMQ.  If the title of the article is not going to be "Using 3rd
> Party JMS Providers with Geronimo" then I think it ought to cover
> configuring connection factories and destinations for ActiveMQ with at
> least the same level of detail as it covers configuration for MQseries
> and OpenJMS.
> Thanks,
>    Aaron
> On 1/24/06, Hernan Cunico <> wrote:
>>Hi Aron,
>>sorry for the delay, have not had internet access in the last couple of days.
>>I just updated the documentation to make it (I hope) more clear.
>>Aaron Mulder wrote:
>>>Which RAR would you use for the OpenJMS and WebSphere examples?  It
>>>seems to say "gerjms" but I'm not sure where to find that. and it
>>>clearly takes different connection parameters than the ActiveMQ RAR.
>>>    Aaron
>>>On 1/16/06, Hernan Cunico <> wrote:
>>>>Hi All,
>>>>here is a documentation update for configuring JMS.

View raw message