geronimo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Dain Sundstrom <>
Subject Re: ClassLoader Architecture
Date Thu, 16 Jun 2005 19:15:49 GMT
On Jun 16, 2005, at 12:04 PM, Bordet, Simone wrote:

> Hi,
> I think your concerns are addressed by JSR 277
> (, scheduled for JDK 7.0 (!).

I saw that on the server side yesterday.  The problem I see with this  
spec is it is already flagged to be part of the JDK, which means that  
when a user has a problem they have to wait for sun to fix them.   
Also JDK 7?  That's ages away.

> Tomcat does some kind of filtering (if you put servlet.jar in
> WEB-INF/lib) but I think the scope for this filtering is well defined
> (or at least restricted).

Yep, Jetty has the same thing.

> Two years ago, I attended a BOF from the SAP guys that work on JMX and
> the SAP J2EE application server, and they showed in few slides that
> their app server was able to do jar versioning for applications (which
> is related to the issues raised). Don't know the details, but it  
> may be
> a place to start to look for information.

I'd love to see more details.  Anyone out there have a link to how  
SAP did this?

> JSR 277 also gives few ideas about its scope and implementation, and I
> don't see ASF in the expert group members.
> This may be of interest as well (jar sealing and package access):

The problem with using sandbox security is you just get a security  
exception.  Also, most custom class loader don't implement package  
security checks correctly.

> Long ago a project at CodeHaus, ClassWorlds if I remember well, was
> about writing a super classloader with features that would have  
> possibly
> allowed versioning and merging.
> Don't know the actual status of that project.
> Considering the ClassLoader leaks chase Dain has done recently, I  
> would
> say it's a delicate issue to play with the current classloader  
> scheme :)

Yep.  One nice thing is it is sooooo core, that when you get it wrong  
you normally find out quickly :)


View raw message