geronimo-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Alex Blewitt <>
Subject Re: [JavaMail] Re: Geronimo standard Sun-API jars
Date Fri, 08 Aug 2003 17:18:27 GMT
> The problem is that there is a lot of code related to Mime parsing and
> Address validation needed to conform to the RFC's in javaMail, there 
> are a
> lot of mail RFC's ( and they would
> require a lot of work to re-implement.

They aren't a requirement of JavaMail; they are a requirement of 
SMTP/MIME and related RFCs. It just so happens that JavaMail also uses 

> I'd be very wary about starting down the road of an Apache clone of 
> javaMail
> unless it really offers serious advantages.

o Easier API to use to generate/send mails
o Less global configuration settings (JavaMail uses global system 
o Conformant JavaBeans representation of MimeMessage
o Use of Mail.getAttachment() to facilitate attachments, rather than 
presenting the low-level layer of how they are transmitted in MIME 
Multipart formats

> Bearing in mind that any clone of javaMail would have to offer pretty 
> much
> interchangeable behaviour with the official product, particularly if 
> it has
> to pass tests, the issue of implementing the Store and Transport 
> interfaces
> is where we should start, and quite probably end too.

I've got an implementation of Transport kicking around from before that 
I can donate to the project, and I'm more than willing to give an 
implementation of JavaMail ago. But since I don't have access to the 
CVS repositories for dumping implementations, I'll have to send it as a 
pretty big patch file :-)


View raw message