forrest-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Ross Gardler <>
Subject Re: [DISCUSS] feeder plugin contract in the view
Date Thu, 31 Mar 2005 00:55:29 GMT
Thorsten Scherler wrote:
> I wrote a feeder contract for the view plugin. 
> The feeder plugin provide a way to display feed as xdoc. 


> Please discuss that because we should find a solution that has framework
> character. IMO the implemented solution can be too inflexible.

Hmmm... my solution seems far too simple and since I have not had the 
time to get into your views work yet I think I must be missing 
something. But here goes anyway...

Use Case

Create a page like this:

|         |                   |               |
|         |                   |               |
|         |                   |   RSS Feed    |
|         |                   |               |
| Menu    |                   |               |
|         |                   -----------------
|         |    Content                        |
|         |                                   |
|         |                                   |
|         |                                   |
|         |                                   |
|         |                                   |

The Problem

How does the view get the RSS content without knowing how to render it 
*and* without having a dependency on the plugin that does the rendering 
(in this case the feeder plugin)


First let us consider what would happen if we were simply requesting a 
page where the RSS feed was the main content.

Forrest would make a request for rssFeed.xml. This request would be 
examined by each plugin in turn, skipping over ones that do not know how 
to generate an XDoc response for the "rssFeed" document. Eventually we 
come to the feeder plugin, which says "hey, I can deal with this 
request". It reads a file, processes it with some XSL and returns an XDoc.

This Xdoc is then processed by the skinning system. First it turns it 
into XHTML, then it adds the navigation sections and we are done.

OK, so no problem so far. Now we want to embed the nugget of RSS data 
into a separate part of the page, the main content is no longer the RSS 

However, if we look carefully at this we see that it isn't really any 
different at the generation stage, it is only at the skinning stage that 
things need to change.

The content to go in the RSS Feed box is still generated by requesting 
"rssFeed.xml", we still get XDoc back. All that needs to change is how 
we skin it.


View raw message