forrest-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From David Crossley <>
Subject Re: [vote] delete old stuff
Date Fri, 26 Nov 2004 06:30:38 GMT
Antonio Gallardo wrote:
> Dave Brondsema dijo:
>>Remember, SVN holds all our history so people can go back and find this
>>stuff if they ever want to.  Deleting it from trunk means we see no
>>value in even attempting to maintain this code.
>>I propose we delete:
>>whiteboard/charts - hasn't been touched for years
>>whiteboard/layout - hasn't been touched for years
>>tools/forrestbar - there has been no demand for compatibility with
>>firefox 0.9+
> I am -1 on that. Why? Somebody remeber the JBoss vs. Apache trouble,
> sometime ago. In short JBoss claimed that the ASF stoled code from him and
> later (thanks that log4j keep his CVS history) Ceki Gulku showed them that
> the code was originaly in the log4j project.
> Removing the history of whatever commit could come to this kind of
> problems. I am not sure if in the future somebody will claim that we
> stolen our own code again!

No, you must be misunderstanding. We are not proposing
to remove the SVN history. Just delete the files.
It is akin to the old CVS concept of putting things
that are not used anymore into the dusty Attic for
safekeeping - the history accompanies the resources.


View raw message