forrest-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Ross Gardler <>
Subject Re: [JIRA] Commented: (FOR-368) Add ihtml to "Deprecation of .ehtml and .ihtml" reference
Date Fri, 26 Nov 2004 00:59:15 GMT

Juan Jose Pablos wrote:
> Ross Gardler wrote:
>> Juan Jose Pablos wrote:
>>> plus, from the user point of view:
>>> When HttpRequest = source then give it as is.
>>> When HttpRequest = supportedFormat then try to tranform it.
>> The problem is that a request for somePage.html is a request for an 
>> HTML page, it does not say wether it should be skinned or not.
> well, think about a png file. If the file is in the directory give it as 
> is. if not try to transform a svg file, if not give an error.
> This rule seems to be applied to other formats like pdf, so doing a 
> transformation on html is an exception.
> To avoid change the extension on all your html files a use-html-as-ihtml 
> property can be set.

Yes, I nearly suggested that in my original reply, but didn't, I wanted 
to see if there was an alternative.

> So we need to find out:
> should be keep diferent extensions for skinned (ihtml) and not skinned 
> html?
> If yes, which is the default skinned extension?
> - ihtml
> - html
> If no, is the skinned html or the not skinned html output the default 
> behavior?
> Is this ok?

The issue that Clay raises implies that there has already been some 
discussion and a decision about this, so I think that we should wait a 
few days to see if anyone remembers such a discussion or has any comments.

If nothing is forthcoming then I will add the property as you suggest, 
which is the default operation doesn't really matter as we can very 
easily change it once it is in SVN. (see I do listen when people say 
"less talk more code" ;-))


View raw message