forrest-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Justin Erenkrantz <>
Subject Re: New ASF site was Re: New Apache XML Site! :-)
Date Sat, 26 Oct 2002 23:36:06 GMT
--On Sunday, October 27, 2002 12:52 AM +0200 Nicola Ken Barozzi 
<> wrote:

> With Forrest we have created for this purpose a "bot" that simply
> checks out a series of sites from CVS, runs the build, and uploads
> them to the website.

I would be against such a bot in use for ASF sites.

There are times when we want to check in a change and do not 
necessarily want to propogate the change immediately (say a pending 
security release).  There are also times when we want an immediate 
deployment - waiting for a bot could be painful (activating the bot 
by trigger could be useful but introduces the first problem).

I'm also concerned about security risks of a remote cron job that 
copies the files to production.  Remember that we can't do the 
generation on the production site.

So, I would strongly prefer that we maintain manual deployment.

> The real goal is to use Forrest *live*, thus serving the *best*
> content to each browser, by doing separate transformation based on
> the request, a thing that a single graphics cannot give.

As I bet you are aware, there will be major performance 
considerations if you go down this route.  I would be reluctant to 
move away from static pages in any ASF environment.  In the past, I 
have worked with sites that used Java/XML/XSLTs to dynamically 
generate the pages and was bitten by their lack of scalibility.  The 
approach the ASF has tried to promote on its webpages is static 
translations rather than dynamic translations.  I believe it fits 
well in our deployment model.

Please remember that the ASF sites handle approximately 2-3 million 
hits a day (may well be much more by now).  Dynamic pages may make 
sense for small sites, but I'd have to be sold on doing this for such 
a large site that has severe resource constraints.  We have no money 
to buy a Fire V480 - we're lucky we have daedalus/icarus.  -- justin

View raw message