directory-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Alan D. Cabrera" <>
Subject Re: Consolidate snickers projects into runtime and compiler
Date Sun, 20 Feb 2005 18:33:28 GMT

Alex Karasulu wrote:

> Alan D. Cabrera wrote:
>> I have merged all the ASN1 code into a unified multi-project maven 
>> setup in asn1/branches/ber-decoder. I propose that we use this setup 
>> instead of the project heirarchy that we have in trunk.  All the code 
>> is neatly in the modules directory.  The maven site target now works 
>> correctly.  Finally, this setup paves the way for the ASN1 
>> refactoring that has been discussed on and off as of late.
>> Thoughts?
> Sorry for taking too long to respond - I had to ask a few questions 
> and get answers regarding your approach with the new proposed maven 
> layout.
> I asked Jason Van Zyl and he does not consider this layout a standard 
> and *HIGHLY* recommends against using this approach.  If Jason and 
> Brett do not recommend this then I don't want to go there.  However 
> the layout thing has nothing to do with code consolidation or making 
> the changes to the architecture that you propose.  Having subordinate 
> runtime and a compiler subprojects can still be the case using the 
> current multiproject setup we have.  There is no need for layout changes.
> If Brett supports it then I may consider it but after weeks of setting 
> up our build as it stands today I do not think he'll buy this new 
> configuration.  He would have set us up this way day one. 

I'm confused, I do not see any work being done on the organization of 
ASN1 sub-project.  If there is a ADS standardization effort underway, 
then I'm happy to follow that.


View raw message