cxf-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Benson Margulies <bimargul...@gmail.com>
Subject Re: Jira Issues: More than half are bugs?!
Date Sat, 10 Oct 2009 19:16:00 GMT
The last time I took a stroll through these, we had lots of the following
form:

1: OP complains without supplying a test case or repro
2: Developer asks for more information
3: nothing else happens


On Sat, Oct 10, 2009 at 1:03 PM, Daniel Kulp <dkulp@apache.org> wrote:

> On Sat October 10 2009 11:52:40 am Christian Schneider wrote:
> > Hi all,
> >
> > I have just looked into what jira issues are open at the moment. There
> > are some things I found.
> > More than half of the open issues are bugs (54%). Of these about 50% are
> > older than one year.
> > Do we really have that many open bugs? I somehow suspect many of these
> > bugs are either not relevant anymore.
>
>
> I started going through last week some of the JIRA's and ended up closing
> off
> about 60 of them, but it's kind of slow going.     According to my notes, I
> got up to CXF-1803 in my review (started at the first one and went up).   I
> was mostly just checking for obviously fixed things though.   I started
> creating a list of stuff that I think may be fixed already or, if not,
> would
> only take a couple hours to diagnose and fix.    When I get some extra time
> (was in meetings all week this week), I was going to start walking through
> some of them.     I included my "notes" below.
>
>
> I suspect a bunch of the "bugs" are also really feature requests.
>
> Dan
>
>
>
> Last review 1803
>
> Don't look too hard: (for me)
> Bug   CXF-758   POST with not body causes exception in REST service
> CXF-681    Set the indent of the generated wsdl
> CXF-675   Refactor http://cxf.apache.org/jaxws schema and
> BeanDefinitionParsers
> CXF-622   HTTPClientPolicy CacheControl type should accept parameters for
> some
> directives
> mprovement   CXF-629   WSDL2Java/cxf-codegen-plugin should not generate
> client
> artifacts when "-impl" flag is provided
>  Bug   CXF-652   Dump incoming/outgoing SOAP messages by enabling logging
>  Improvement   CXF-920   Need system property for output client request and
> responses
>  Bug   CXF-806   java2wsdl gives poor diagnosis of bad JAXB bean class
>  Bug   CXF-857   Unable to Deploy CXF 2.0 service on Glassfish (Sun App
> Server)
> CXF-879   preceeding / in cxf-servlet.xml causes link displayed in services
> panel to fail
> CXF-881   Class cast exception when running JCA Integration sample
> CXF-1087   Spring control of jetty server
> CXF-1091   Javadoc missing for dispatch client capability
> Improvement   CXF-1111   For samples, upgrade to a Servlet 2.4-compatible
> deployment descriptor
> Bug   CXF-1159   Remove FixedExtensionDeserializer once XmlSchema delivers
> their fix
> Sub-task   CXF-1259   CXF-1243 NPE when SEI methods throws RemoteException
> Bug   CXF-1282   Can't set the excutor from JAXWS API
> Bug   CXF-1283   Forking another thread to invoke the service
> implementation
> in ServiceInvokerInterceptor is not working
> CXF-1402   MTOM missing pieces
> Improvement   CXF-1427   wsdl2java: Generate first class Java enum for
> inline
> element
>  Bug   CXF-1561   pom.xml is missing a dependency when CXF is configured to
> handle JSON/REST messages
>  CXF-2386 - abdera-extensions-main and abdera-i18n are required by
> cxf-bundle-
> minimal but not present in any repository
>  Improvement   CXF-2268   Collapse Atom Feed and Entry providers and
> support
> Atom reflectively
>  Bug   CXF-1668   Wrong encoding using JMS Transport
>  CXF-1679   Schema entries with same targetNamespace produces error in
> wsdl2java
>  CXF-1706   Aegis binding behaves differently than JAXB in regards to MTOM
> support
>  CXF-1731   Unexpected control based on the namespace of the soap:body
> element
>  CXF-1791   Exception feedback - AuthHeader invalid
>  CXF-1817   wsdl2java RandomValueProvider gives StackOverflowException on
> bidirectional reference
>  CXF-1818   java2ws -createxsdimports with packages that reference other
> packages should have schemaLocation in schema import
>  CXF-1838   Space in project name causes ?wsdl parameter to fail
>  CXF-1939   WSDLToJava doesn't generate Service interface class, when wsdl
> has
> 2 services names that differ for an underscore
>  CXF-1983   Allow aegis binding at global level as well
>  CXF-2015   Add capability to configure per-request client interceptors
>  CXF-2035   Issues with SOAPAction
>  CXF-2053   wsdl2java should log reason for switching from wrapped to bare
> in
> verbose mode
>  CXF-2208   Local Transport Client Timeout can't be configured
>  CXF-2308   Invalid signature of
>
> cxf.apache.org/javadoc/latest/org/apache/cxf/ws/addressing/AddressingProperties.html#setTo
>
>
>
>
> Test cases:
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CXF-1133
> CXF-1234 <https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CXF-1133%0ACXF-1234>
> Array confusion for Doc/Lit/Bare methods
> Improvement   CXF-1235   Suggestion: use @WebParam cues when
> auto-generating
> request wrappers for Doc/Lit/Wrapped
> Bug   CXF-1407   Item element with xmlns="" in Exception with arrays of
> compex
> objects
> CXF-1497   Supplied WSDL soap:address not being updated with actual host
> name
> when queried.
> CXF-2183   wsdl2java "only one global bindings customization is allowed"
> with
> embedded imported schema namespace
> CXF-2223   Proxy authentication failure with SSL tunneling
> CXF-2244   Server accepts an unsigned message when the policy requires a
> signed message.
>  CXF-2293   cxf-codegen-plugin fails with 'Mojo Execution Failed'
>
>
>
> Request for info:
> Bug   CXF-2192   missing dependency on codegen plugin
> CXF-2232   CXF wsdltojava client generation fails to generated the service
> with targetnamespace
>  CXF-2277   Error stopping Tomcat after executing a one-way Web Service
>  Bug   CXF-2283   Exposed Webservice disappear after a child spring app
> context closed
>  CXF-2284   org.apache.cxf.BusException: No binding factory for namespace
> http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/soap/ registered."
>
>
>
>
>
>
> On Sat October 10 2009 11:52:40 am Christian Schneider wrote:
> > Hi all,
> >
> > I have just looked into what jira issues are open at the moment. There
> > are some things I found.
> > More than half of the open issues are bugs (54%). Of these about 50% are
> > older than one year.
> > Do we really have that many open bugs? I somehow suspect many of these
> > bugs are either not relevant anymore.
> >
> > So my proposal is to comment on each issue and ask that the reporter
> > checks if the bug is still present and that each
> > issue with no reply for say a month will be closed. Then after a month
> > we close all issues with no replys.
> >
> > What do you think?
> >
> > Greetings
> >
> > Christian
> >
> >
> >
> > See issues by type:
> >
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/RunPortlet.jspa?portletKey=com.atlass
> >
> ian.jira.plugin.system.portlets:projectstats&projectid=12310511&showclosed=
> > false&sortDirection=asc&sortOrder=natural&statistictype=issuetype
> >
>
> Bug   CXF-758   POST with not body causes exception in REST service
> CXF-681    Set the indent of the generated wsdl
> CXF-675   Refactor http://cxf.apache.org/jaxws schema and
> BeanDefinitionParsers
> CXF-622   HTTPClientPolicy CacheControl type should accept parameters for
> some
> directives
> mprovement   CXF-629   WSDL2Java/cxf-codegen-plugin should not generate
> client
> artifacts when "-impl" flag is provided
>  Bug   CXF-652   Dump incoming/outgoing SOAP messages by enabling logging
>  Improvement   CXF-920   Need system property for output client request and
> responses
>  Bug   CXF-806   java2wsdl gives poor diagnosis of bad JAXB bean class
>  Bug   CXF-857   Unable to Deploy CXF 2.0 service on Glassfish (Sun App
> Server)
> CXF-879   preceeding / in cxf-servlet.xml causes link displayed in services
> panel to fail
> CXF-881   Class cast exception when running JCA Integration sample
> CXF-1087   Spring control of jetty server
> CXF-1091   Javadoc missing for dispatch client capability
> Improvement   CXF-1111   For samples, upgrade to a Servlet 2.4-compatible
> deployment descriptor
> Bug   CXF-1159   Remove FixedExtensionDeserializer once XmlSchema delivers
> their fix
> Sub-task   CXF-1259   CXF-1243 NPE when SEI methods throws RemoteException
> Bug   CXF-1282   Can't set the excutor from JAXWS API
> Bug   CXF-1283   Forking another thread to invoke the service
> implementation
> in ServiceInvokerInterceptor is not working
> CXF-1402   MTOM missing pieces
> Improvement   CXF-1427   wsdl2java: Generate first class Java enum for
> inline
> element
>  Bug   CXF-1561   pom.xml is missing a dependency when CXF is configured to
> handle JSON/REST messages
>  CXF-2386 - abdera-extensions-main and abdera-i18n are required by
> cxf-bundle-
> minimal but not present in any repository
>  Improvement   CXF-2268   Collapse Atom Feed and Entry providers and
> support
> Atom reflectively
>  Bug   CXF-1668   Wrong encoding using JMS Transport
>  CXF-1679   Schema entries with same targetNamespace produces error in
> wsdl2java
>  CXF-1706   Aegis binding behaves differently than JAXB in regards to MTOM
> support
>  CXF-1731   Unexpected control based on the namespace of the soap:body
> element
>  CXF-1791   Exception feedback - AuthHeader invalid
>  CXF-1817   wsdl2java RandomValueProvider gives StackOverflowException on
> bidirectional reference
>  CXF-1818   java2ws -createxsdimports with packages that reference other
> packages should have schemaLocation in schema import
>  CXF-1838   Space in project name causes ?wsdl parameter to fail
>  CXF-1939   WSDLToJava doesn't generate Service interface class, when wsdl
> has
> 2 services names that differ for an underscore
>  CXF-1983   Allow aegis binding at global level as well
>  CXF-2015   Add capability to configure per-request client interceptors
>  CXF-2035   Issues with SOAPAction
>  CXF-2053   wsdl2java should log reason for switching from wrapped to bare
> in
> verbose mode
>  CXF-2208   Local Transport Client Timeout can't be configured
>  CXF-2308   Invalid signature of
>
> cxf.apache.org/javadoc/latest/org/apache/cxf/ws/addressing/AddressingProperties.html#setTo
>
>
>
> Last review 1803
>
>
> Test cases:
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CXF-1133
> CXF-1234 <https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CXF-1133%0ACXF-1234>
> Array confusion for Doc/Lit/Bare methods
> Improvement   CXF-1235   Suggestion: use @WebParam cues when
> auto-generating
> request wrappers for Doc/Lit/Wrapped
> Bug   CXF-1407   Item element with xmlns="" in Exception with arrays of
> compex
> objects
> CXF-1497   Supplied WSDL soap:address not being updated with actual host
> name
> when queried.
> CXF-2183   wsdl2java "only one global bindings customization is allowed"
> with
> embedded imported schema namespace
> CXF-2223   Proxy authentication failure with SSL tunneling
> CXF-2244   Server accepts an unsigned message when the policy requires a
> signed message.
>  CXF-2293   cxf-codegen-plugin fails with 'Mojo Execution Failed'
>
>
>
> Request for info:
> Bug   CXF-2192   missing dependency on codegen plugin
> CXF-2232   CXF wsdltojava client generation fails to generated the service
> with targetnamespace
>  CXF-2277   Error stopping Tomcat after executing a one-way Web Service
>  Bug   CXF-2283   Exposed Webservice disappear after a child spring app
> context closed
>  CXF-2284   org.apache.cxf.BusException: No binding factory for namespace
> http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/soap/ registered."
>
>
>
>
> --
> Daniel Kulp
> dkulp@apache.org
> http://www.dankulp.com/blog
>

Mime
  • Unnamed multipart/alternative (inline, None, 0 bytes)
View raw message