couchdb-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Christian Grobmeier <>
Subject Re: the great git project
Date Thu, 17 Nov 2011 19:56:51 GMT
On Thu, Nov 17, 2011 at 8:52 PM, Mikeal Rogers <> wrote:
> Is the expectation that *all* of the concerns added to this page will be resolved?

I think no.

Actually I am one of these guys without any concerns.

I think we should show that git is compatible with the Apache way and
that git will not destroy communities (not more than svn, when used

Therefore it will be good to make some kind of reports, to see, what
concerns actually are important and which ones are acceptable when

> On Nov 17, 2011, at November 17, 201111:48 AM, Christian Grobmeier wrote:
>> Hello all,
>> i have had a long discussion on members@ recently on couchdb and git.
>> I am also here to help.
>> My main concern was, that nobody were able to tell me how long this
>> "experiment" would run and how success will be measured. There is
>> still no answer, but i think this is crucial.
>> As some of you hopefully know, there is an expectation that couchdb
>> delivers guidelines how to use git @ asf. If they are not done in a
>> reasonable time (i have heard 4 months), couchdb will be reverted back
>> to svn.
>> The board has mentioned several community aspects we need to cover.
>> I am not sure if there are still technical issues which need to be covered.
>> Anyway, I would like to suggest we do:
>> a) set up a wikipage, in which we can collect all upcoming concerns
>> and questions
>> b) try to report on git@couchdb regulary, best all 4 weeks
>> c) try to outline how you are working here and the problems wchi might
>> occur when looking at a)
>> d) hopefully deliver a strong and great document which can be voted upon on
>> I have some concerns already in my inbox, so I am volunteering to post
>> them to the wiki page as first step. Just.... where?
>> I hope my suggestion is OK for you. I am open to other proposals of
>> course, I just want to make git coming to the asf.
>> Cheers
>> Christian
>> On Thu, Nov 17, 2011 at 8:41 PM, Randall Leeds <> wrote:
>>> On Thu, Nov 17, 2011 at 03:05, Brian LeRoux <> wrote:
>>>> Hey folks, some you may remember me from such projects as PhoneGap
>>>> which is now under incubation as Callback. Our mentors have informed
>>>> us in order for Git to be accepted the CouchDB 'experiment' must
>>>> succeed. So we are joining you here to help see that the experiment
>>>> does succeed, and as fast as possible!
>>> Excellent! Paul Davis has been spearheading the git move.
>>>> We have been informed that documentation on the process of
>>>> contribution via Git in "the Apache Way" has yet to be writ (or is
>>>> possibly has been started but isn't yet complete). Seems like a good
>>>> place to start --- can you point me at the appropriate starting point
>>>> for contribution here? Also any other suggestions required steps
>>>> really appreciated!
>>> There's little difference in contributions between git and svn. Our
>>> workflow so far has still been to accept patches via JIRA with the
>>> "Grant license to ASF..." checkbox.
>>> There are some hooks on the Apache infra side that prevent certain
>>> verboten histories from occurring. Paul can elaborate on those.
>>> For release documents, this is up to date and was used for CouchDB's
>>> 1.1.1 release:
>>> That's all I got for now.
>>> -Randall
>> --


View raw message