continuum-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Emmanuel Venisse <emman...@venisse.net>
Subject Re: Design - Replacing Continuum's Web Framework
Date Fri, 02 Dec 2005 17:13:25 GMT
Carlos,

do you have a simple sample that use acegi?

Emmanuel

Carlos Sanchez a écrit :
> Acegi is based in servlet filters for the protection of urls, so the
> web framework used won't impact its use.
> Are you planning protecting just urls or any other stuff? acegi can do
> authorization and authentication at class, method and instance level
> too, but I think that's only needed in a few types of applications.
> 
> I was in a project using JSF and seems that it's adoption is getting
> speed, with different implementations and a lot of extensions,
> utilities and tools. I've heard very good things about using
> Facelets+JSF to create components, and also about Spring MVC, but
> seems to me that people using Spring MVC is moving to JSF.
> 
> My 2 cents
> 
> 
> On 12/1/05, John Casey <jdcasey1779@yahoo.com> wrote:
> 
>>Hi everyone,
>>
>>We've been talking about this for quite awhile in various channels, and
>>I wanted to take a few minutes and formalize the discussion. I'll
>>capture the highlights of this discussion in the wiki afterwards. I'll
>>start by posting my own thoughts, and let you all respond.
>>
>>Up to this point, Continuum has been built on a web framework called
>>Summit, which is part of the Plexus project, and using Velocity as the
>>page rendering technology. Summit is still a very young project, and as
>>a result has its problems. Given the proliferation of web frameworks out
>>there, it seems natural to wonder whether we couldn't find something
>>more mainstream and mature that will fit our needs.
>>
>>The key goal here is to make the web tier as easy to understand as
>>possible by the widest possible audience, without sacrificing anything
>>in the way of quality. To that end, criteria might include:
>>
>>* tool support
>>* maturity in the form of multiple final releases (or at least one)
>>* good integration with JSP (it's the most widely-used rendering
>>     technology out there for java)
>>* ready availability of good documentation
>>* integration with a decent security library (think acegi)
>>* others?
>>
>>Another big concern is that we need to be able to make this web
>>framework integrate with Plexus without too much funny business. I don't
>>expect that to be a big problem, but worth mentioning.
>>
>>I know that a certain amount of work has been done by Trygve and
>>Emmanuel to get WebWork running inside Plexus. Is this the best
>>framework? A quick check of Amazon showed three books, only one of which
>>is completely concerned with WW. SpringMVC might be another option,
>>since it has probably the most natural integration with Acegi. There is
>>a certain amount of overlap between Spring and Plexus that we'd probably
>>have to map with a custom Spring container or something, but that's
>>likely to be everywhere, since dependency injection is such a hot topic
>>(and very useful).
>>
>>What do you all think?
>>
>>-john
>>
> 
> 
> 
> 


Mime
View raw message