Mailing-List: contact dev-help@commons.apache.org; run by ezmlm
Precedence: bulk
Reply-To: "Commons Developers List" <dev@commons.apache.org>
Received-SPF: pass (athena.apache.org: domain of jak-commons-dev@m.gmane.org
 designates 80.91.229.3 as permitted sender)
To: dev@commons.apache.org
From: =?UTF-8?B?SsO2cmc=?= Schaible <joerg.schaible@gmx.de>
Subject: Re: [VOTE] Release of Commons Collections 4.0 based on RC3
Date: Wed, 13 Nov 2013 22:59:36 +0100
Lines: 188
Message-ID: <l60snu$q32$1@ger.gmane.org>
References: <5281482B.2030206@gmail.com> <l5uclk$4ia$1@ger.gmane.org>
 <CAJSjvwvukJ0XpOGbRYfMq9hVsop_FgKH-VuG3qEfNk8=-cDY+g@mail.gmail.com>
 <l5vir4$clb$1@ger.gmane.org> <l609uv$aoe$1@ger.gmane.org>
 <5283D13A.4000507@gmail.com>
Reply-To: joerg.schaible@gmx.de
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8Bit
User-Agent: KNode/4.10.5

Thomas Neidhart wrote:

> On 11/13/2013 05:39 PM, Jörg Schaible wrote:
>> Jörg Schaible wrote:
>> 
>>> Hi Thomas,
>>>
>>> Thomas Neidhart wrote:

[snip]

>>>> For IBM JDK 6: I did already ignore several tests (due to problems with
>>>> the TreeMap implementation there) if run with this JVM but obviously
>>>> something has changed since then, need to check.
>>>
>>> I can tell you this evening (in ~6 hours), which version I used exactly.
>>> However, IIRC the number of executed tests were for me always the same.
>>> Maybe the check for IBM JDK 1.6 failed?
>> 
>> ===================== %< ===============
>> $ java -version
>> java version "1.6.0"
>> Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build pxa6460sr9fp2-20110625_01(SR9
>> FP2)) IBM J9 VM (build 2.4, JRE 1.6.0 IBM J9 2.4 Linux amd64-64
>> jvmxa6460sr9-20110624_85526 (JIT enabled, AOT enabled)
>> J9VM - 20110624_085526
>> JIT  - r9_20101028_17488ifx17
>> GC   - 20101027_AA)
>> JCL  - 20110530_01
>> ===================== %< ===============
> 
> I tested with this version:
> 
> java version "1.6.0"
> Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build pxi3260sr12-20121025_01(SR12))
> IBM J9 VM (build 2.4, JRE 1.6.0 IBM J9 2.4 Linux x86-32
> jvmxi3260sr12-20121024_126067 (JIT enabled, AOT enabled)
> J9VM - 20121024_126067
> JIT  - r9_20120914_26057
> GC   - 20120928_AA)
> JCL  - 20121014_01
> 
> and got 3 failures from a recently added test, for which I forgot to add
> the ignore rules.
> 
> Could you output me the result of this for your IBM JDK version:
> 
>         final String vmName = System.getProperty("java.vm.name");
>         final String version = System.getProperty("java.version");

=========================== %< ===========================
java.specification.version: 1.6
java.specification.vendor: Sun Microsystems Inc.
java.specification.name: Java Platform API Specification
java.vm.vendor: IBM Corporation
java.vendor: IBM Corporation
java.vm.name: IBM J9 VM
=========================== %< ===========================

Failing and erroneous tests:

=========================== %< ===========================
Failed tests: 
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet.testMapEntrySetIteratorEntrySetValue:1656 
expected:<true> but was:<false>
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet.testMapEntrySetIteratorEntrySetValue:1656 
expected:<true> but was:<false>
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionToArray2:1097 
toArrays should be equal expected:
<[Entry(key=again [28], value=againv, parent=all [14], left=again [28], 
right=all [14], predecessor=again [28]), Entry(key=all [14], value=allv, 
parent=foo [13], left=again [28], right=bar [28], predecessor=again [28]), 
Entry(key=bar [28], value=barv, parent=all [14], left=baz [44], right=blah 
[9], predecessor=baz [44]), Entry(key=baz [44], value=bazv, parent=bar [28], 
left=bar [28], right=baz [44], predecessor=baz [44]), Entry(key=blah [9], 
value=blahv, parent=ROOT, left=ROOT, right=tmp [11], predecessor=bar [28]), 
Entry(key=foo [13], value=foov, parent=hello [12], left=all [14], right=gosh 
[15], predecessor=gosh [15])]> but was:<[Entry(key=foo [13], value=foov, 
parent=hello [12], left=all [14], right=gosh [15], predecessor=gosh [15]), 
Entry(key=blah [9], value=blahv, parent=ROOT, left=ROOT, right=tmp [11], 
predecessor=bar [28]), Entry(key=baz [44], value=bazv, parent=bar [28], 
left=bar [28], right=baz [44], predecessor=baz [44]), Entry(key=bar [28], 
value=barv, parent=all [14], left=baz [44], right=blah [9], predecessor=baz 
[44]), Entry(key=all [14], value=allv, parent=foo [13], left=again [28], 
right=bar [28], predecessor=again [28]), Entry(key=again [28], value=againv, 
parent=all [14], left=again [28], right=all [14], predecessor=again [28])]>
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionToArray2:1097 
toArrays should be equal expected:<[Entry(key=key2 [58], value=value, 
parent=key [14], left=key [14], right=key2 [58], predecessor=key2 [58]), 
Entry(key=nonnullkey [13], value=value, parent=hello [12], left=key [14], 
right=nonnullkey [13], predecessor=nonnullkey [13]), Entry(key=see [13], 
value=seev, parent=you [12], left=see [13], right=we'll [14], 
predecessor=see [13]), Entry(key=tmp [11], value=tmpv, parent=blah [9], 
left=hello [12], right=you [12], predecessor=we'll [14]), Entry(key=we'll 
[14], value=we'llv, parent=see [13], left=tmp [11], right=we'll [14], 
predecessor=we'll [14]), Entry(key=you [12], value=youv, parent=tmp [11], 
left=see [13], right=you [12], predecessor=you [12])]> but 
was:<[Entry(key=you [12], value=youv, parent=tmp [11], left=see [13], 
right=you [12], predecessor=you [12]), Entry(key=we'll [14], value=we'llv, 
parent=see [13], left=tmp [11], right=we'll [14], predecessor=we'll [14]), 
Entry(key=tmp [11], value=tmpv, parent=blah [9], left=hello [12], right=you 
[12], predecessor=we'll [14]), Entry(key=see [13], value=seev, parent=you 
[12], left=see [13], right=we'll [14], predecessor=see [13]), 
Entry(key=nonnullkey [13], value=value, parent=hello [12], left=key [14], 
right=nonnullkey [13], predecessor=nonnullkey [13]), Entry(key=key2 [58], 
value=value, parent=key [14], left=key [14], right=key2 [58], 
predecessor=key2 [58])]>
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionToArray2:1097 
toArrays should be equal expected:<[Entry(key=baz [44], value=bazv, 
parent=bar [28], left=bar [28], right=baz [44], predecessor=baz [44]), 
Entry(key=blah [9], value=blahv, parent=ROOT, left=ROOT, right=tmp [11], 
predecessor=bar [28]), Entry(key=foo [13], value=foov, parent=hello [12], 
left=all [14], right=gosh [15], predecessor=gosh [15]), Entry(key=gee [28], 
value=geev, parent=gosh [15], left=gee [28], right=golly [43], 
predecessor=gee [28]), Entry(key=golly [43], value=gollyv, parent=gee [28], 
left=goodbye [46], right=gosh [15], predecessor=goodbye [46]), 
Entry(key=goodbye [46], value=goodbyev, parent=golly [43], left=golly [43], 
right=goodbye [46], predecessor=goodbye [46]), Entry(key=gosh [15], 
value=goshv, parent=foo [13], left=foo [13], right=gee [28], 
predecessor=golly [43]), Entry(key=hello [12], value=hellov, parent=tmp 
[11], left=foo [13], right=nonnullkey [13], predecessor=key [14]), 
Entry(key=key [14], value=null, parent=nonnullkey [13], left=hello [12], 
right=key2 [58], predecessor=key2 [58]), Entry(key=key2 [58], value=value, 
parent=key [14], left=key [14], right=key2 [58], predecessor=key2 [58]), 
Entry(key=nonnullkey [13], value=value, parent=hello [12], left=key [14], 
right=nonnullkey [13], predecessor=nonnullkey [13]), Entry(key=see [13], 
value=seev, parent=you [12], left=see [13], right=we'll [14], 
predecessor=see [13])]> but was:<[Entry(key=see [13], value=seev, parent=you 
[12], left=see [13], right=we'll [14], predecessor=see [13]), 
Entry(key=nonnullkey [13], value=value, parent=hello [12], left=key [14], 
right=nonnullkey [13], predecessor=nonnullkey [13]), Entry(key=key2 [58], 
value=value, parent=key [14], left=key [14], right=key2 [58], 
predecessor=key2 [58]), Entry(key=key [14], value=null, parent=nonnullkey 
[13], left=hello [12], right=key2 [58], predecessor=key2 [58]), 
Entry(key=hello [12], value=hellov, parent=tmp [11], left=foo [13], 
right=nonnullkey [13], predecessor=key [14]), Entry(key=gosh [15], 
value=goshv, parent=foo [13], left=foo [13], right=gee [28], 
predecessor=golly [43]), Entry(key=goodbye [46], value=goodbyev, 
parent=golly [43], left=golly [43], right=goodbye [46], predecessor=goodbye 
[46]), Entry(key=golly [43], value=gollyv, parent=gee [28], left=goodbye 
[46], right=gosh [15], predecessor=goodbye [46]), Entry(key=gee [28], 
value=geev, parent=gosh [15], left=gee [28], right=golly [43], 
predecessor=gee [28]), Entry(key=foo [13], value=foov, parent=hello [12], 
left=all [14], right=gosh [15], predecessor=gosh [15]), Entry(key=blah [9], 
value=blahv, parent=ROOT, left=ROOT, right=tmp [11], predecessor=bar [28]), 
Entry(key=baz [44], value=bazv, parent=bar [28], left=bar [28], right=baz 
[44], predecessor=baz [44])]>

Tests in error: 
  AbstractSortedMapTest$TestTailMap>AbstractMapTest.testMapRemove:1002-
>AbstractSortedMapTest$TestViewMap.verify:138->AbstractMapTest.verify:1942-
>AbstractMapTest.verifyValues:2013 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionIteratorRemove:834-
>verify:1707 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionRemoveAll:930-
>verify:1707 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapKeySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionIteratorRemove:834-
>verify:1786 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapKeySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionRemoveAll:930-
>verify:1786 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractSortedMapTest$TestTailMap>AbstractMapTest.testMapRemove:1002-
>AbstractSortedMapTest$TestViewMap.verify:138->AbstractMapTest.verify:1942-
>AbstractMapTest.verifyValues:2013 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionIteratorRemove:834-
>verify:1707 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionRemoveAll:930-
>verify:1707 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapKeySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionIteratorRemove:834-
>verify:1786 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapKeySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionRemoveAll:930-
>verify:1786 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractSortedMapTest$TestTailMap>AbstractMapTest.testMapRemove:1002-
>AbstractSortedMapTest$TestViewMap.verify:138->AbstractMapTest.verify:1942-
>AbstractMapTest.verifyValues:2013 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionIteratorRemove:834-
>verify:1707 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapEntrySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionRemoveAll:930-
>verify:1707 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapKeySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionIteratorRemove:834-
>verify:1786 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
  AbstractMapTest$TestMapKeySet>AbstractCollectionTest.testCollectionRemoveAll:930-
>verify:1786 » ArrayIndexOutOfBounds
=========================== %< ===========================

[snip]

Cheers,
Jörg


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@commons.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@commons.apache.org